Tuesday, September 19, 2023

Third time's a charm: What are *you* to make of SHORT FILM?

September 20 is the 1-year birthday of the novel Most Famous Short Film of All Time. Thank you, today and every day, for your time.


"Stop. I saw you about to click away from this review. I promise you, this will make sense.

Or rather, you will make sense of it when you experience the book. The sense you make may vary from the sense I have made — the senses I have made, really, forming a new one each of the three times I’ve read Short Film.

As I read, what sorts of ideas come ricocheting in? Sheesh — the nature of time, the nature of reality, being trans, being Jewish, storytelling, logic and its limits, pop culture, evil… yadda yadda, I could list themes ad absurdum, and what would you have? A boring list-review that would likely scare you off of the book. “What,” you’d ask, “am I to make of all this?”

That’s the point."

— Dale Stromberg, Most Famous Short Film of All Time: A Review, Medium


Three people and a pink convertible. Detail from the book cover of Most Famous Short Film of All Time. Author: Tucker Lieberman. Cover artist: Cel La Flaca.

Cover art by Cel La Flaca

Monday, September 18, 2023

A few book titles spotted on preorder

As background, Emily Wilson translated The Odyssey (published 2018)...

...and her translation of the Iliad comes out in a week.

Published last week: Cecilia Márquez's book Making the Latino South: A History of Racial Formation

Will be published tomorrow: Ross Gay's book The Book of (More) Delights: about "the trillion mysterious ways this glorious earth delights us"

On pre-order to ship March 2024: Garrett Bucks's book The Right Kind of White: a memoir of self-understanding of white identity to support "racial accountability."

two people in a flying ark

It could happen (and is happening) here: Transphobia is fascism

Naomi Klein wrote:

"As the transnational extreme right — from Giorgia Meloni to Jair Bolsonaro — landed on anti-trans fearmongering as a powerful adhesive to bind together its Frankenstein of “inclusive nationalism,” many of the same people in the wellness world who railed against the unnaturalness of Covid vaccines have begun to speak more openly about the supposed naturalness of the gender binary, and of traditional family roles. Far from the unlikely bedfellows they first seemed to be, large parts of the modern wellness industry are proving to be all too compatible with far-right notions of natural hierarchies, genetic superiority, and disposable people."

— Naomi Klein. Doppelganger: A Trip into the Mirror World. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2023.

More from Naomi Klein in Doppelganger:

"Similar attempts at diversifying the hard-right base can be seen in Australia and France. These movements are still built around hate and division — on scapegoating migrants; on pathologizing trans youth; on bashing teachers trying to support these students or tell a truer story of their nations’ past; and on scaremongering about communists and Islamists. “Inclusive nationalism” just means that they have found some new blocs of voters who are also looking for scapegoats, and not all of them are white, or male.

The endgame is not hidden. Bannon tells his posse that they are going to “run this country for one hundred years, [for] every ethnicity, every color, every race, every religion — that’s an inclusive nationalism.”

[Speaking of France, in May 2024, over 10,000 people protested anti-trans legislation.]

And Klein again:

"As recently as 2020, Wolf had strongly pushed back against the attacks on trans rights by some feminists of her generation, hinting they had become tools of the right. Now she was making common cause with the very women who linked all-gender bathrooms with sexual assault. The results of this 'huge victory' showed, she said, the 'gigantic plutonium weapon” represented by “suburban women who will do anything for their children' — parents who had become aware that 'there are dark forces arrayed at their kids ... all kinds of weird abuse of children going on.'"

weeping stone statue
Based Brenda tweets March 11, 2023: Too many people in this stupid fucking country seem to think fascism arrives suddenly to ominous organ music, wearing a black cape and twirling a sinister moustache.<br><br>It doesn’t.<br><br>It takes root over many years, and it always begins with demonising and scapegoating minorities.
Jeff Sharlet tweets March 6, 2023: Even now, we are afflicted by the double (un)consciousness of "It can't happen here" and the even more insidious secret desire among many for some part of "it" to happen--"Well, maybe it would be better if homeless people were all moved to one place..."
Matt Seybold tweets March 9, 2023: New Yorker: You know that racist historian everybody hates? We’re going to fawningly profile him. New York Times: We’re going to give an education column to a TERF. Wall Street Journal: Hold my beer. Screenshot of article headline: College should be more like prison

Rep Andy Biggs tweets June 9, 2023: We have now reached a war phase. Eye for an eye.
Rep. Clay Higgins tweets June 8, 2023: President Trump said he has 'been summoned to appear at the Federal Courthouse in Miami on Tuesday, at 3 PM.' This is a perimeter probe from the oppressors. Hold. rPOTUS has this. Buckle up. 1/50K know your bridges. Rock steady calm. That is all.

Both of these tweets are referenced in "GOP Congressmen All But Declare War After Trump Indictment", Matt Shuham, HuffPost, June 9, 2023


i don’t know how to effectively convey to cis people that the anti-trans movement is a fascist one that is advancing terrifyingly fast and that its aims and impacts will not be limited to trans people
simultaneously i wish that more prominent trans activists were really explicit about the fact that transphobia is undergirded by antiblackness / white supremacy as a whole bc we cannot possibly hope to meet the moment without, at the very least, an understanding of that fact
ok lol gonna get ahead of this tweet getting big and self promo: i’m a trans filipinx journalist, i cover anti-trans violence/policy/etc. for @them and also culture stuff, i have no idea what the fate of this website is but i can be found here and on ig at the same handle

In the replies, another person recommends "the chapter "Antifascism through the Lens of Transgender Identity" by Emily Gorcenski in ¡No pasarán!: Antifascist Dispatches from a World in Crisis."


In reply to a screenshot of a tweet from the username 'Gender critic' who said 'girls need blouses and skirts to reflect their biological differences,' Natacha tweets: 'Gender-critical' transphobia has revealed its narratives of 'biological sex' and 'sex-based rights' as the deeply sexist, misogynistic and patriarchally oppressive ideology trans people always said it was. It is about forcing everyone, including children, into rigid...
…gender roles based on repressive assumptions about their sexuality, reproductive function and roles in life. It rejects pretty much everything that is core to feminist principles and   wants to enforce an oppressive cultural determinism on women and girls in particular ... their cult of 'biological sex' is in fact just the co-option of a very restricted patriarchal interpretation of biological determinism - something feminists have always fought against - as a rhetorical weapon to remove trans people’s human rights. This has resulted...
...in them adopting an extreme & particularly repressive patriarchal belief-system that would not be out of place in Victorian England or most totalitarian states. It needs to do this to justify its policies of transphobic exclusionism by rigidly defining its imposition ... of an ideology of 2 biologically-determined gender roles in all areas as a means of excluding, oppressing & harming trans people. 'Gender-critical' transphobia has literally become what trans people always said it would; an extreme right-wing patriarchal gender fascism ...
no wonder it is attracting so much funding from far-right homophobic, anti-abortion groups, support from the worst abusive misogynistic right-wing men & from billionaire media. In reality 'Gender-critical' transphobia is all the far-right’s Christmases & birthdays come ... at once. It is a small group of deeply conservative, hate-driven women and right-wing men pretending to support them giving the current wave of global fascism an added veneer of legitimacy in order to further their blind hatred and desire for elimination of trans people.

“The GOP’s obsessive focus on punishing trans people is, in every way, a feminist issue — it arises from fascism’s predictable and eternal obsession with white fertility and ensuring “traditional,” patriarchal gender roles.“ Read this story from Jude Ellison S. Doyle on Medium (friend link)

"It’s definitely been getting worse. A lot of people who have been out since the '70s and '80s are saying that this is an unprecedented level of public hate. Even if there's been progress around rights for a lot of people, there's a whole lot more hostility."
— Florence Ashley, interviewed by OpenMind, April 2024


“I’m trying to point out something tricky about how transphobia works: Bigots don’t think of you as “really” being your assigned gender, because you’ve failed to conform to it. They don’t think of you as “really” being your own gender, because you weren’t assigned to it. They don’t see you as a woman, they don’t see you as a man, and they definitely don’t see you as non-binary; they see you as a collection of all the worst stereotypes about women, and all the worst stereotypes about men, and they switch between gendered stereotypes depending on which ones seem the most likely to hurt you.

What I’m saying is that Gadsby was right: For the most part, people will see you as whatever gender they’re allowed to beat up.” [emphasis mine]

— Jude Ellison Doyle, Gadsby, Gadfly, June 6, 2023


IDK the collective trauma is off the charts right now. I really do think that so much of what we’re seeing politically right now is just,, traumatized people clinging to easy answers. The easy answers being to get rid of the transsexuals, apparently. I fucking hate it here.

— The Transfeminine Review (@thetransfemininereview.com) January 9, 2025 at 3:19 PM

See also: "This Novel Imagines Fascism in the 1930s USA". It's a 4-minute read on Medium.

Sandy Ernest Allen wrote in September 2025:

I also often contemplate those colleagues of mine in media who’d rather write edgy conservative takes for the likes of the New York Times — rather than go on Fox News where their views may be more welcome and, indeed, normal. I similarly contemplate those politicians who’d rather run as Democrats than as Republicans but who want to nonetheless repeat anti-trans talking points. I think about why such folks would rather pretend, to themselves and/or their audiences, that they’re not allied with the fascists — even as they launder right-wing rhetoric.

Saturday, August 26, 2023

How many seconds, minutes, hours, days, or years will carbon capture restore?

On atmospheric carbon removal: Express it in time

Study shows support for carbon removal but great concern over solar manipulation by Ulrich von Lampe, Mercator Research Institute on Global Commons and Climate Change (MCC) gGmbH, Phys.org, October 30, 2023

As of 2024, Germany isn't hitting its emissions targets, but is proposing to be a leader in carbon removal.

earth seen from space

The first large-scale industrial carbon capture and storage facility in the US is reportedly leaking. The CCS operation at ADM's Decatur facility is meant to demonstrate that the technology can be deployed safely. 😶 www.reuters.com/sustainabili...

[image or embed]

— Dr. Genevieve Guenther (@doctorvive.bsky.social) October 3, 2024 at 5:42 PM

As always: there is excessive skepticism about readily deployable and scalable climate solutions, and excessive credulity about experimental ones (particularly those that preserve the status quo rather than requiring deeper systemic change) www.latimes.com/environment/...

[image or embed]

— Ket-arbon Emissions Joshi (@ketanjoshi.co) October 25, 2024 at 2:57 AM

A really very very spectacular run-through of how carbon removal advocates REALLY used to say the quiet part out loud: literally, 'we are doing this to keep fossil fuels going' by @wimcarton.bsky.social, who's got a book on this w/ Andreas Malm coming out in Oct -->>> youtu.be/jlQhV1ag8FI

[image or embed]

— Ket-arbon Emissions Joshi (@ketanjoshi.co) May 28, 2024 at 11:51 AM

See this:

"In the 1990s, hope – coupled with doubt – was the fossil fuel industry’s antidote to the precautionary principle, the sensible idea that some problems had such dire implications that humanity should err on the side of caution even if the science was not completely settled. When George Bush was president, he was initially so concerned by the impact of fossil fuels on the climate that he looked into regulating the oil industry. But he backed away from this on the grounds that future generations would probably develop new technologies to solve the problem. Call that dumb, call that wishful thinking, or call that hope, the result was the same: no action.

That once again looks to be the temptation of Britain’s Labour government in promising £22bn for carbon capture and storage projects. This technology is supposed to catch greenhouse gas emissions before they can enter the atmosphere. But it is incredibly expensive, has never worked at the necessary scale and, until now, has largely been a ruse for the petroleum industry to continue pumping."

— Jonathan Watts, Would abandoning false hope help us to tackle the climate crisis?, The Guardian, Oct 24, 2024

FOLKS this is why you keep versioned copies of important emissions and energy data!!!!!!!!! Equinor's reported carbon capture amounts have been quietly revised downwards after they fixed a faulty transmitter: www.desmog.com/2024/10/28/n...

[image or embed]

— Ket-arbon Emissions Joshi (@ketanjoshi.co) October 28, 2024 at 6:24 AM

Okay, I have to do a thread on this pretty amazing article because it is just seriously chockers with eye-opening stats about 'direct air capture' - ie, sucking up air and trying to remove carbon dioxide from it news.mit.edu/2024/reality...

[image or embed]

— Ketan Joshi (@ketanjoshi.co) November 26, 2024 at 3:26 AM

Capturing direct from combustion (CCS), vs from air: “The difference is akin to needing to find 10 red marbles in a jar of 25,000 marbles of which 24,990 are blue [the task representing DAC] versus needing to find about 10 red marbles in a jar of 100 marbles of which 90 are blue [the task for CCS]"

— Ketan Joshi (@ketanjoshi.co) November 26, 2024 at 3:28 AM

On the sheer volume of air you need to suck up: "Given that low concentration, removing a single metric ton (tonne) of CO2 from air requires processing about 1.8 million cubic meters of air, which is roughly equivalent to the volume of 720 Olympic-sized swimming pools" (or, ~2.2 tonnes of air)

— Ketan Joshi (@ketanjoshi.co) November 26, 2024 at 3:32 AM

more or less on this team. the model should be more like remediation after oil spills - funded via the stick of punitive litigation, rather than the carrot of tax credits or offset sales

— Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò (@olufemiotaiwo.bsky.social) November 27, 2024 at 8:52 AM

Your 'moment of doom' for Sept. 4, 2025 ~ In other words... "if the total available geological storage capacity would be exclusively used for CO2 removal and no further emissions would be produced by other activities at that point, a maximum 0.7°C warming reversal would be possible..."

[image or embed]

— Prof. Eliot Jacobson (@climatecasino.net) September 4, 2025 at 8:23 AM

“With current trends suggesting warming up to 3°C this century, using all of the safe geological storage wouldn’t even get us back to 2°C,” said lead author Matthew Gidden, research professor at the Center for Global Sustainability at the University of Maryland.

[image or embed]

— Dr. Aaron Thierry (@thierryaaron.bsky.social) September 23, 2025 at 7:23 PM

Read: The Collapse of Confidence in Carbon Capture

#CarbonCapture #cdnpoli #ClimateChange #MarkCarney #ClimateSky www.scmp.com/opinion/asia...

[image or embed]

— Bentley (@bigclimate.bsky.social) January 6, 2026 at 4:43 PM

On political nostalgia and the voice of self-described civility

old guy in a suit, smiling while typing on an old-school typewriter

Richard Hanania, Rising Right-Wing Star, Wrote For White Supremacist Sites Under Pseudonym: Hanania is championed by tech moguls and a U.S. senator, but HuffPost found he used a pen name to become an important figure in the “alt-right.” Christopher Mathias, HuffPost, Aug 4, 2023

when I broke story abt Hanania being Nazi, almost none of folks he was tied to - Substack, NYT, WaPo, Atlantic, Stanford, UT, U of Austin, WSJ, Andreesen, Thiel, Ramaswamy, Sacks, Vance, Federalist Society - would comment my book describes how this was indicator of this fascist political moment

[image or embed]

— Christopher Mathias (@letsgomathias.bsky.social) February 25, 2026 at 9:03 AM

"Three years ago this month I published an exposé for HuffPost about a guy named Richard Hanania. It revealed the rising right-wing star, beloved by Silicon Valley billionaires and future Vice President JD Vance, had used the pen name “Richard Hoste” in the early 2010s to secretly write for the most extreme white supremacist websites. “Hoste” wasn’t just some random online shitposter, but one of the formative “intellectual” voices of the nascent “alt-right,” the fascist movement that would later partner with Donald Trump to take the White House and help shape his first and second presidencies." — Christopher Mathias, The Handbasket, August 13, 2026

Perhaps relevant:

Billionaire Marc Andreessen says he has "zero" introspection, and that the idea itself is a modern invention.

[image or embed]

— More Perfect Union (@moreperfectunion.bsky.social) March 16, 2026 at 11:39 AM

Thomas Zimmer ("Moralizing Nostalgia Leads to Bad History – and Helps the Anti-Democratic Right" Substack, August 22, 2023) calls David Brooks "a prime example of a vacuous pundit class with a regrettably large influence that presents itself as reasonable and above the fray while only ever preaching the gospel of status-quo preservation." This particularly regards his September 2023 feature for The Atlantic, “How America Got Mean.” Brooks's 11,000-word article is based on "pervasive longing for a golden past that never really existed," as Zimmer paraphrases it; Americans used to grow up, Zimmer goes on to paraphrase Brooks, within a "system that trained 'the heart and body' rather than just the intellect, made sure people understood there was an 'objective moral order' that is beyond individual perspective, and emphasized personal virtue above all else." But then came political liberalism that concerned itself with fighting oppression and abandoned interest in "moral reasoning." Those people now, as Brooks puts it, seek to "fill the moral vacuum with politics and tribalism." Concerned with getting themselves recognized, people are unable to pursue a common good. And so what Brooks is doing is asserting a different kind of individualism. He says people should stop pursuing their political self-interest and instead develop their own moral character to fulfill their own soul. Then, somehow, a political common good will emerge. Brooks doesn't, as Zimmer points out, attempt to reconcile his theory with the simple observation that U.S. political life was not in fact more egalitarian before the mid-20th century when supposedly, according to Brooks, interest in moral formation crumbled.

I discussed this in my November 2024 article on Medium: My Identity is a 'Luxury Belief', and Other Reasons Trump Won

Regarding Brooks's August 2023 column, which I discussed in my Medium story & in one before it, see this article on Vox: "I regret to report the economic anxiety theory of Trumpism is back: In David Brooks’s new column, he asks the American elite if they’re the baddies. But he’s actually telling them a comforting fiction. Zack Beauchamp, Aug 4, 2023

In a follow-up article, "Why America’s Elites Love to Decry 'Polarization,'" Zimmer recommends Ezra Klein's Why We're Polarized but says it has a big problem: "what the author lays out is, by his own admission, not adequately interpreted as 'polarization.'" The Republicans are racially homogeneous, so they tend to radicalize. The Democrats are diverse, so they can't be extremist, because they have to hold diverse interests to together. Klein therefore refers to the phenomenon as “asymmetrical polarization.” Zimmer doesn't think this term makes much sense. Why use the word "polarization" at all? The two sides aren't the same, as "there is no liberal version of Fox News and the rightwing media bubble, the Democrats don’t have a Trump, and there is no equivalent on the Left to the influence of reactionary and white nationalist forces inside the GOP."

"The nostalgic longing for a supposedly better, pre-polarization era shines through even in generally excellent work, such as Steven Levitsky’s and Daniel Ziblatt’s investigation of How Democracies Die", a 2018 book in which the authors "settle on a warning against the dangers of 'polarization' and combine it with praise for the mid-twentieth-century consensus era that was supposedly characterized by 'egalitarianism, civility, sense of freedom.'"

Similarly, according to Zimmer, Jill Lepore in These Truths (2018)

"laments the emergence of radically partisan media on both left and right resulting in what she calls 'mutually assured epistemological destruction'. The metaphor is striking — but it hinges on the questionable characterization of Fox News and MSNBC as equally partisan and extreme. When Lepore gives a detailed account of Rush Limbaugh's outsized influence on conservative politics or the machinations of conspiracy theorist Alex Jones, it becomes clear that there are simply no equal counterparts on the Left. And yet, the narrative of polarization indicates that there should be, and encourages the search for (false) equivalence. Ultimately, it primes people to accept a politics focused on turning the clock back to a supposedly better past – before all the nastiness..."

I still remember afternoons with my dad in the car listening to Limbaugh. I think people who are surprised by trumpism never heard his show.

— Menno (@menno.bsky.social) December 24, 2025 at 9:53 AM

Why say that Right and Left are polarized if it's not really true? Well: "For elite centrists, the 'polarization' framework and all the talk of radicalization and extremism 'on both sides' is a way to legitimize and re-assert their own status at the top." In other words, if you portray yourself as standing in an objective place, safely apart from two ridiculously warring factions, you defend the superiority of your own perspective and whatever it is you want to say.

This is about recovery from "the fracturing of the white elite consensus in the 1960s." Woe is us:

"Is there nothing America’s elite can agree on anymore? There is: Polarization is the problem! 'Polarization' is so attractive partly because the interpretation confirms the unease with which America’s elite has looked at the contentious developments that have shaped the country since the 60s – providing alleviation by legitimizing the nostalgia for 'consensus.' Blaming 'Polarization' never breeds contention, it makes everybody nod in approval; it engenders unanimity. That’s the genius of the polarization narrative: It provides the language for a lament that blames nobody and everybody, and satisfies the longing for unity – which it constantly fuels in turn! – by offering a consensual interpretation; it is elite consensus re-established through the back door."

I left a comment on this one too.

Note: I wrote about Why We're Polarized" on (unpaywalled "friends link"), and I wrote about How Democracies Die on this blog.


Brooks (and others) have argued that leftists should learn to make friends with people who don't share their beliefs. A.R. Moxon represents (while criticizing and satirizing) a view that Brooks put forward in another recent essay, describing it as a "gnostic idea" of a mind/body separation in which politics doesn't affect one's social life at garden parties:

"They’re a bloodless thing, politics, abstract, almost administrative sometimes. Making decisions about who you associate with based on political views is apparently like getting into a screaming fight over an improper stapling methodology on one’s TPS reports, or ending a friendship over pizza toppings. And at other times, political views are sacrosanct, holy, something you shouldn't ever even bring up much criticize, the most special and personal part of a person’s belief structure, something that a decent person would be no more likely to critique, much less reject, than they would be likely to tell a new mother that her baby is ugly.

I have noticed that whether political views are trivial or sacred seems to depend on the point the professional mourner of crumbling civility is trying to make in the moment, in order to bolster civility. They are usually trivial when we are meant to make friends despite them. They are usually sacrosanct when we try to point out what they are.

But some of us have notices that politics are neither of these things, have noticed that politics are where power is arranged and distributed, and have been listening not to the civility mourners or the supremacists they defend, but rather to the many people who are directly harmed by harmful policies driven by harmful political views, who have no luxury to believe in false separations. They know that politics are, in fact, a matter of spiritual alignment, and that spirit not something to do with ghosts, but with the blood and guts of how collective belief touches their lives."

(To which I left a comment on Mastodon: "'No one will be friends with me' seems a cousin of 'I’m being canceled.' In both complaints, the supremacist objects to a lack of attention or fame they feel they’re inherently owed, though it be a kind of attention they may not truly want, since when it's given to them in a genuine form along with any criticism, they persist in their original complaint ('everyone’s intolerant and hostile,' 'I’m being canceled') and tack on another: “my right to free speech is being violated." The box did not allow space for the sentence with which I wanted to conclude: "Because criticism violates their purported right not to be criticized, a right they implicitly claim is the true meaning of free speech.")

To bring it back to the "blood and guts":

Evan Urquhart: When people talk about making friends with people who have different politics, my first impulse is usually to try and humanize myself, as a trans person, and try to explain what they're asking- that I make friends with people who have a psychopathic indifference to my wellbeing. Aug 27, 2023

Jude Ellison S. Doyle (discussing other writers and not mentioning Brooks specifically) coins the term "Reasonable White Guy Voice". Doyle describes it as

"a tone of affable, detached professionalism and erudition, mixed with just enough in-group references to seem contemporary — the voice of someone who owns both a worn-out Black Flag t-shirt and a framed diploma from Harvard. The voice is medium-deep, medium-rich, personable, unaccented; it emits a consistent, low, diffused warmth, like the pink glow coming off a Himalayan salt lamp, but never strays into a register that could be considered emotional. Emotion would undermine its credibility, which is immense. Niceness without empathy, opinion without emotion, credibility without vulnerability, is what Reasonable White Guy Voice is all about.

* * *

...the people most taken in by RWGV are not the reading public. ... The intended audience for this performance is other journalists, who mistake Reasonable White Guy Voice for intelligence and authority because it’s what they’ve been taught to strive for in their own work.

* * *

Reasonable White Guy prose is not only written by white guys, but it is always written for white guys, because that is the worldview it’s meant to capture: That of someone so insulated from the world and its suffering that he can watch as it burns and not feel a thing."

(I left a comment on the Medium article.)

A further comment I wish to make: Doyle wrote that "Being a Reasonable White Guy might make some truths more available, but it will also obscure others from view. ... A truth is a fact within its proper context." I'd add that, when we don't have context, we can't point out when someone is talking like a mob boss. The mob boss never publicly says "I offed that guy" in exactly those words, and instead says "It's too bad what happened to him," and everyone knows he's taking responsibility — or, at least, he's gloating that he'd gladly off someone else in similar circumstances. He's not expressing empathy for the victim. His words have a meaning that isn't literal and self-encapsulated; their meaning comes from the context. So when we lack context, we can't interpret threats or warn others of them. Authoritarians communicate publicly with each other, and their victims are silenced by being told approximately: Well, the authoritarian didn't say that. He didn't say what you're accusing him of saying. He expressed empathy and sorrow. And so language is scooped up by the powerful and its power-plays are denied to anyone who doesn't already have power, thereby further disempowering, abusing, and victimizing them. This makes it difficult to have a truth-based discourse about important things.

Richard Hanania, Rising Right-Wing Star, Wrote For White Supremacist Sites Under Pseudonym. Hanania is championed by tech moguls and a U.S. senator, but HuffPost found he used a pen name to become an important figure in the “alt-right.” Christopher Mathias, Aug 4, 2023, Updated Aug 7, 2023

Oh, and an update on Hanania:

Lincoln Michel tweets on September 18: While not surprising, it's quite galling how Hanania wrote one insincere blog post about no longer being racist to heaps of praise and support from the 'contrarian' and centrist sets and then... went immediately back to posting the same racist things without skipping a beat.

Here's Ken White, weighing in on Hamish McKenzie of Substack defending his choice to speak with Hanania: "Taking everyone at their word that they’re not a Nazi, and deciding to accept that they mean racist things in non-racist ways, is a value judgment too. It’s a decision; you can’t plausibly spin it as a refusal to make a decision." (Ken White, "Substack Has A Nazi Opportunity," Dec 21, 2023)

Rep Mike Collins tweet showing a crowd of white students counterprotesting a Gaza protest, including one in the foreground who's imitating a monkey, to mock a Black woman (not shown). May 3, 2024. His text is: Ole Miss is taking care of business. The words 'From Richard Hanania' under the image, inside the tweet, is highlighted in red.

(This image is from an article by Judd Legum on May 8.)

The Washington Post says:

"The version of the video that Collins shared is credited to Richard Hanania, someone who previously espoused white supremacist views that he has since said he disavows. In sharing the video, Hanania wrote, 'This video from Ole Miss is beautiful, but guys, please put away the phones. Be in the moment when you’re mocking the Hamas loving fat girl.'"

After the 2024 election: "if a lack of empathy was what swung voters i think the party that made lacking empathy their central political tenet might have lost" — Peter on Bluesky

if you live around conservatives, a common bumper sticker reads “liberalism is a mental disorder.” you’ll see effigies of dem politicians, unhinged screeds about satan-worshipping dems written on lawn signs. this stuff gets ignored while any hint of condescension from liberals is treated as endemic

— Peter (@notalawyer.bsky.social) November 26, 2024 at 4:27 PM

On which point, see: Outrage over offending red America highlights a major double standard in media: Right-wing media clutch pearls after a Republican strategist mocked Trump supporters on TV. But when Trump attacks millions of Americans, they and mainstream journalists simply accept it as normal. Parker Molloy, Media Matters, January 30, 2020

hanania is a dull, uninteresting writer whose main contribution to the discourse is being a gutter racist. naturally, he is being feted by elite publications. makes you wonder.

[image or embed]

— jamelle (@jamellebouie.net) May 14, 2025 at 7:37 AM

Replacing one form of thought control with the other…HANANIA LITERALLY BRAGGED THAT IS WHAT HE WOULD DO IF HE HAD THE CHANCE

— Adam Gurri (@adamgurri.liberalcurrents.com) May 13, 2025 at 8:44 PM

He only wanted to fire people like Nikole Hannah-Jones. He didn't expect it would also come for the sciences.

— Aubrey Gilleran (@aubreygilleran.bsky.social) May 13, 2025 at 8:46 PM

reminder that "IQ" bullshit and obsession with "race realism" and genetic essentialism is what in large part helped the far right build their modern platform by wooing racist academics under the guise of scientific rigour. its of course all pseudoscientific bullshit meant to justify genocide

[image or embed]

— Mira (SPOOKYNOUNS IN BIO) (@thefreeradical.org) November 18, 2025 at 12:17 PM

Sources

"Richard Hanania and the Reasonable White Guy Voice," Jude Ellison S. Doyle, Medium, August 16, 2023

"If You Want To Be Friends, Then Why Aren’t You Friendly?": A look at one of the most alarming and pressing problems of our age: the much-lamented fact that "the left" won't be friends with "the right," over "political views." The Reframe (Substack). A. R. Moxon. August 26, 2023

"Moralizing Nostalgia Leads to Bad History – and Helps the Anti-Democratic Right" Thomas Zimmer, Substack, August 22, 2023

David Brooks on political polarization, New York Times, March 2, 2019

Why America’s Elites Love to Decry “Polarization”, Thomas Zimmer, Substack, September 25, 2023

Related to which, my essays on Medium:

When we disagree on politics and I lose a friend, and Yet another pro-discrimination argument (on Brooks and Jonathan Rauch).

Rabbi Ruti Regan - Mar 12, 2019 - There is nothing shameful about being afraid of people who have made it clear that they want to hurt you.

See also: For some Never Trumpers, the main problem with Trump is his aesthetic or his tone, not his fascism. Some people believe they have nothing at stake. So for them, "the fundamental problem with Trump has always been that he is gauche. The 14th amendment remedy is also gauche. So, to them, it is no better than reelecting Trump." Dave Karpf, Bluesky

Similarly:

"Even people who despised Trump only really seemed to despise the grotesqueness of him; when it came to the authoritarian abuses he proposed, they weren't only on board, they saw these abuses as necessary, even intrinsic to safety. For example, try suggesting that the answer to ongoing systemic nationwide open corruption and brutality in policing is to maybe not fund the police as if it were a wartime army. Or suggest that maybe we don't need to spend all our money on the military industrial complex. Or suggest that a country that imprisons people for profit as part of a growth industry needs to engage in prison abolition.

* * *

...what I mean by "a spiritual sickness"—a preference within a society for lies over truths, and a preference within society's norms and institutions and laws to show preference to those who believe the lies over those who tell the truth. I began to suspect that—while we should work for political change, and while we ought to work to make our laws just, and their application and enforcement fair—it wasn't going to be enough to simply readjust the mechanisms of our existing order. We were going to have to do something foundational about our underlying beliefs—the architecture of our collective belief that defines and determines the shape of reality upon which that order sits. And then we were going to have to translate those beliefs into actions that reflected those truths—this particularly if we are in that specific subset of we to whom our society's norms and institutions and laws show preference and deference: men, and "white" people, and wealthy people, and employed, and able-bodied, and straight, and Christian, and so forth."

— An Interview with Author A.R. Moxon About 'Very Fine People' (with Parker Molloy), May 2024

Sarah Kendzior says ("The King," Sarah Kendzior’s Newsletter, Substack, Sept 12, 2024):

"Americans are forced to live forever on the precipice, while politicians and pundits feign opposition for profit. They need you to see Trump as a novel and singular threat, instead of a long-time player in multiple corrupt networks — because they inhabit those same networks, as do their financial backers.

My guess is that you, dear reader, would like autocracy to actually be defeated — in the form of Trump, and in general.

But that is not what The Autocracy Cottage Industry wants. They would rather join the Trump administration and then write tell-all books about crimes they witnessed but did not stop. They would rather pass the same repressive policies Trump did but cloak them in gentler rhetoric. They fundraise off your fear."

For the "Vichy Democrats or Never-Trump Republicans or the predatory scammers surrounding them," Kendzior goes on, "there is only Trump and Not-Trump. Your thinking must never extend beyond that binary." That is, if Trump does it, it's bad; if anyone else does it, it's licit.

Kendzior continues:

"[Harris's] warm response to Dick Cheney’s approval should be greeted with alarm — particularly when war criminals are welcomed into the Harris fold while antiwar protesters are rejected.

It is obvious what happened even if some are reluctant to cop to it: Bush-era Republican operatives, unable to function in the chaos of MAGA, saw an opportunity to remake the Democratic Party, which had been lurching to the right since the 1990s, and took it. They left receipts: the conservative Lincoln Project is Harris’s fourth biggest donor. Change in Democratic Party policy is determined by donations — not only the Lincoln Project’s — and then rationalized with the Trump/Not-Trump binary."

On May 10, 2024, Trump complained that he has a gag order in his hush-money election interference trial: "Everybody can say whatever they want. But I'm not allowed to say anything about anybody." (CNN) More precisely, Trump can't publicly comment on the judge's family, the district attorney's family, court staff or their families, prosecutors or their families, or prospective jurors or their families. Why? Because it puts those people at risk, and such intimidation can prejudice the outcome of the trial. Defendants in criminal trials are not allowed to threaten or pressure people who have a role in their trial. That's what Trump is complaining about when he says "I'm not allowed to say anything about anybody."

To campaign, you do need to explain things to people

Seriously, y'all. It's not helping your cause.

[image or embed]

— -𝚖𝚘𝚡 (@moxiest.art) Apr 21, 2024 at 2:16 PM

Legitimately had someone say "this shouldn't have to be explained" and like, bro, do you not understand what campaigning is?

— -𝚖𝚘𝚡 (@moxiest.art) Apr 21, 2024 at 2:26 PM

Being civil to enslavers means covering up their crime?

George Washington enslaved people. "This is an extensively documented fact," CNN reminds us. And yet Trump, on June 22, 2024:

During a speech to the Faith and Freedom Coalition, a conservative Christian group, Trump criticized proposals to change the names of schools, military facilities and other places that honor slaveowners and Confederate leaders. (Under President Joe Biden, the Army has renamed nine installations that had been named for Confederate generals.) And Trump said, “How about George Washington high school? ‘We want the name removed from that high school.’ They don’t know why. You know, they thought he had slaves. Actually I think he probably didn’t.’”

What is the point of denying slavery? To be extra nice to the enslavers?

This is slavery denialism.

Being civil to insurrectionists means...what?

Apparently Joe & Jill will ride with Trump & Melania to the Capitol tomorrow. Either Trump is a threat to democracy, & guilty of an insurrection, or not. I believe he is. Biden claimed to believe he is, too. But Biden & many top Dems didn't actually believe it. Otherwise, how to explain this?

— Mehdi Hasan (@mehdirhasan.bsky.social) January 19, 2025 at 8:50 PM

Although Kennedy said “democracy” was not guaranteed to survive, what he meant was “decorum” He has no problem with democratic collapse. He just wishes people weren’t so rude about it. ballsandstrikes.org/legal-cultur...

[image or embed]

— Barred and Boujee aka Madiba Dennie (@audrelawdamercy.bsky.social) October 1, 2025 at 9:15 AM

Sierra Club, 2025: Free Download: Tips for having difficult conversations!

The spirit of Thanksgiving has infused the White House press office today, bringing us together in a blessed moment of harmony and goodwill.

[image or embed]

— Bill Grueskin (@bgrueskin.bsky.social) November 27, 2025 at 12:34 PM

Mamdani: For too long, those fluent in the good grammar of civility have deployed decorum to mask agendas of cruelty

[image or embed]

— Acyn (@acyn.bsky.social) January 1, 2026 at 3:00 PM

Hanania is a white supremacist piece of shit and so is everyone who has contributed to his rehabilitation

[image or embed]

— Jonathan M. Katz (@katz.theracket.news) August 13, 2026 at 6:39 PM

Actual adult people who work in the mainstream press talk to this guy and take him seriously. He's a white supremacist, yes, but he's also just a premium sexless dork.

[image or embed]

— Ben Collins (@bencollins.bsky.social) August 29, 2026 at 3:02 PM

Who demands civility from whom?

At a rally on Oct 3, 2026:

"“Just get out and vote,” Trump said at a rally for US Senator Jon Husted, gubernatorial candidate Vivek Ramaswamy and other Republicans. “If you do that, we’re going to win, and we’re going to win big, and we’re going to shove it up their ass.”"

Trump on Democrats: "They are a bunch of dumb son of a bitches"

[image or embed]

— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar.com) October 3, 2026 at 7:57 PM

Thursday, August 24, 2023

Ships have to wait 3 weeks to cross the Panama Canal

The Panama Canal was dug relatively shallow compared to the ocean on either side. It fills with water using a system of water locks. This depends on nearby lakes being full. Unfortunately, when those lakes suffer from drought, ships simply have to wait to cross the canal.

See also: "A severe drought is affecting the Panama Canal. That’s not a good sign for supply chains — or your holiday shopping." Alicia Wallace, CNN, August 26, 2023

"The dry weather in Panama shows no sign of letting up with the El Niño weather phenomenon wreaking havoc to schedulers working for the country’s canal administration.

The Panama Canal Administration warned yesterday that following the driest October on record, the volume of daily transits will be cut further.

At its maximum, the canal can handle 40 ship transits a day, a figure that has been eroded this year as months of record drought take their toll. In tandem, canal administrators have been forced to cut maximum draft limits for ships transiting the waterway’s larger neopanamax locks by close to 2 m."

— Record dry weather forces further dramatic cuts at the Panama Canal, Sam Chambers, Splash247, November 1, 2023

Every seemingly small choice we make — how to travel, what to buy, where and whom to buy from, and how long we're willing to wait — will make a difference on the future of the planet. Related to this, please see: "Both Climate Optimists and Doomers are Wrong: It’s not hopeful complacency or smug nihilism from here on, it’s selfless mitigation", T. J. Brearton, Medium, August 23, 2023. It's a 7-minute read on Medium.

Hey, so "deporting" doesn't seem like the right word if you have no connection to the country to which you're being moved: U.S. deporting African and Asian migrants to Panama in diplomatic breakthrough, Camilo Montoya-Galvez, CBS News, February 13, 2025

Trump wants to reclaim the Panama Canal. He’d be taking on a waterway facing crisis, Laura Paddison, CNN, February 21, 2025

ocean

El Niño-caused drought in Panama is likely to raise prices on everything from medicine to fuel, Hira Humayun, CNN, August 21, 2026

Wednesday, August 23, 2023

Climate: non-linear changes, tipping points, and 3°C obliteration

trees
Feb 8, 2020 Ben See tweets: A devastating non-linear climate event is about to shock humanity and it will probably have something to do with the Arctic.
1. 95% of old ice gone
2. ice free by 2021-2031
3. fastest warming place on Earth
4. CH₄ release now unprecedented
5. permafrost collapse is irreversible

Funnily enough spotted this just after attending a @h2020protect.bsky.social webinar on the #Greenland tsunami of 2017, which was caused by an event very similar to this one, where a mountainside collapsed into a fjord. Thawing permafrost likely a cause in Nugatsiaq, did it also play a role here?

[image or embed]

— Ruth Mottram (@ruthmottram.bsky.social) November 18, 2024 at 9:33 AM

See these articles:

Risks of 'domino effect' of tipping points greater than thought, study says, Guardian, December 20, 2018

The Last Butterflies? Nick Haddad, Scientific American, September 19, 2019

Dr. Genevieve Guenther tweets on Aug 22, 2023: It is very hard to write about the projected catastrophes of 3°C of warming. I keep having to step away from my desk to cry. Mad respect to the scientists & journalists who write about this stuff, rather than the comparatively (emotionally) easier stuff of political malfeasance.
Glen Peters, Aug 19 2023 tweets:
According to the #IPCC AR6 Synthesis Report, to limit global warming to '1.5°C with no or limited overshoot', then global CO2 emissions decline:
* 48% in 6 years
* 80% in 14 years
* 99% in 24 years
(thanks @_david_ho_ for reminding me to remind people)

Here's the IPCC synthesis Peters is linking to.

In response to Peters, David Ho says:

Aug 23, 2023 David Ho tweets: Even if CO₂ emissions decreased annually as much as during the pandemic lockdown, we wouldn't achieve our climate targets. While individuals made huge sacrifices, the system remained. This shows that individual action will not solve climate change. We need the system to change.

  "We’re murdering the planet right now, in case you didn’t know. Or if we’re not murdering it, we’re making it uninhabitable for ourselves specifically, because we seem to believe we can’t afford to keep it inhabitable.
  It seems like a bad time to engage in fights to murder each other, but the urges to murder the planet and to murder each other seem conjoined. It might be a good time to fight whatever urges are leading us to do such wasteful things in a time of great need."
— A.R. Moxon, "Hurting The Right People": It has happened before, but there is nothing to compare it to now. Spirits of harm and lack; spirits of solidarity and abundance. The Reframe (Substack), Oct. 14, 2023

See also: "Climate Change is Expensive, But That’s Not the Point". It's a 10-minute read on Medium.

In case you missed it

You Can’t Pull a Lever to Write Your Book (and 69 Other Lessons)

Everything I know about writing a complicated and difficult book On November 4, the Book Bazaar on Twitch aired my 52-minute recorded v...