Wednesday, October 4, 2023

Hey, your phone's about to ring (USA)

2:20 p.m. Eastern: A nationwide test of the Emergency Alert System and Wireless Emergency Alerts.
(per CNN)
EAS alert goes to radio and TV. (EAS was first tested in 2011. This is the 7th test of EAS.)
WEA alert goes to your cell phone. (This is the second-ever WEA test that goes to consumer cell phones.)

In 2004, I wrote an article on the reform of the public warning system. It was published in April 2005. So that's why I'm thinking about your phone ringing.

red rotary phone

Tuesday, October 3, 2023

In Hebrew, movement toward gender-neutral language

Many languages are gendered. As a culture's understanding of gender evolves and changes, its language changes too. One modern language experiencing these languages is Hebrew.

According to a 2022 article in the New York Times, in Hebrew, "every object has an assigned gender — a table is masculine and a door is feminine, for example — and the language lacks gender-neutral terms for people and groups of people." In the past, when speaking about, or to, a mixed-gender group, people have tended to use the masculine plural. Obviously, women find this exclusionary. So today, to be inclusive, "Israelis are increasingly using both the masculine and feminine forms of each verb and pronoun, along with corresponding adjectives, or are mixing them up." Some people write with "slash signs and dots" to mix the genders. Government forms already ask for "'Parent 1' and 'Parent 2,' which includes same-sex couples."

The Academy of the Hebrew Language doesn't have a solution; for the moment, it has simply recommended has recommended moderation in the use of the masculine and feminine. The head of the Academy’s Scientific Secretariat has said: "People delude themselves that if they change the language to fit their agenda, they will win their battles for some cause or other."

Here's an example of a modern question:

"'When I want to send a message to a group including men, women and nonbinary people, how do I address that group in a way that includes everyone?' asked Michal Shomer, an activist who has been pushing to make Hebrew less gender-specific and who has created a set of all-inclusive characters for the Hebrew alphabet."
ahava, the Hebrew word for love, on a rainbow pride background
Image: Wikimedia Commons

Source

In Israel, a Biblical Tongue Meets Gender Politics A linguistic revolution is underway in the quest for more gender-inclusive language for Hebrew, whose modern form adopted grammatical norms from 3,000 years ago. Not everybody is on board. Isabel Kershner, Aug. 1, 2022

This article mentions that "the United Nations has issued guidelines for nondiscriminatory communications in the six official languages of the organization: Arabic, Chinese, English, French, Russian and Spanish." It also linked to a "24-page manual of gender-inclusive language guidelines" (PDF, in Hebrew). As well: "Some American students and academics have tried to build gender-inclusive language projects for Hebrew, but they have not caught on here."

Monday, October 2, 2023

Saskatchewan: School policy on under-16s name/gender is facing scrutiny

When you're divorcing or separating in Saskatchewan, why is it so important to put your values about affirming your child's gender in your Saskatchewan parenting plan?

Image: Seeking Fortune, or Emigrant Boy by Nicholas Chevalier, 1887 oil painting

"Education Minister Dustin Duncan announced earlier in the day that going forward, schools must now seek the permission of parents or guardians before allowing students under the age of 16 to change what the province refers to as their 'preferred' name and pronouns. ... [Lisa] Broda [Saskatchewan Advocate for Children and Youth] said her office found out about the policy, titled Use of Preferred First Name and Pronouns by Students [PDF], through the media and had not been advised of the changes."
— Youth advocate reviewing Sask. policy requiring schools to get parental permission for pronoun changes: Province also banning outside groups from giving sex-ed presentations in schools. Alexander Quon, CBC News, Aug 22, 2023

According to Adam Goldenberg, a partner with McCarthy Tétrault and legal counsel for UR Pride, which has asked to block the new policy, the policy can't be enforced yet. A CBC article on September 29 quoted Goldenberg as saying that "gender-diverse young people in Saskatchewan" can currently ask a "trusted adult" to "refer to them by their chosen name, their chosen pronouns, even if they haven't come out to their parents so don't have parental consent."

[Justice Michael Megaw wrote:] "There is no indication...that the [Education] Ministry discussed this new Policy with any potential interested parties such as teachers, parents, or student" [and] "no indication any expert assistance was enlisted to assist in determining the effect of the Policy. Finally, there is no indication the Ministry sought any legal assistance to determine the constitutionality of the Policy with respect to any potential considerations regarding the Charter." [Meanwhile] "Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe is reiterating his claim that his government's school pronoun policy was based on extensive consultations with parents, teachers and others..." However, when asked for evidence, Moe said only: "That evidence would ultimately be forthcoming, I would presume. ... I'll leave what happens in the courtroom to the lawyers."
Sask premier says school pronoun policy based on wide consultation, but judge says there's no evidence of that: Premier Scott Moe says he'll recall legislature Oct. 10 to invoke notwithstanding clause. Jason Warick, CBC News, Sep 29, 2023

Meghan McKie wrote about this on Medium: "Saskatchewan's New Series 'Transphobia': A Show About Nothing!" (paywalled; be a Medium member, please)

Sunday, October 1, 2023

'Instrumentarianism': It's not what totalitarianism was

The "dark heart of surveillance capitalism" is "a new type of commerce that reimagines us through the lens of its own distinctive power, mediated by its means of behavioral modification." This power "sustains and enlarges the surveillance capitalist project." In The Age of Surveillance Capitalism, Shoshana Zuboff names this power:

"instrumentarianism, defined as the instrumentation and instrumentalization of behavior for the purposes of modification, prediction, monetization, and control. In this formulation, 'instrumentation' refers to the puppet: the ubiquitous connected material architecture of sensate computation that renders, interprets, and actuates human experience. 'Instrumentalization' denotes the social relations that orient the puppet masters to human experience as surveillance capital wields the machines to transform us into means to others' market ends."

the car, detail from the book cover of Most Famous Short Film of All Time
Detail from the cover of Short Film. Artist: Cel La Flaca

Once, she says, "the language of imperialism" was "the only framework at hand with which to articulate and resist" a certain "new power's murderous threats." This new power was eventually named totalitarianism, as it was indeed different from imperialism. The word "totalitarianism" was coined by Giovanni Gentile and was later popularized in Gentile's book co-written with Mussolini, The Doctrine of Fascism (1932). That book began by saying that "Fascism is totalitarian and the Fascist State — a synthesis and a unit inclusive of all values — interprets, develops, and potentates the whole life of a people." It described fascism as "a spiritual attitude." As Zuboff further explains, "the state was to be understood as an inclusive organic unity that transcends individual lives. All separateness and difference are surrendered to the state for the sake of this superordinate totality." For totalitarianism, "each individual inner life must be claimed and transformed by the perpetual threat of punishment without crime." That's more than "mere conformity," and the result can't be achieved through "remote control." It was essentially political, though it "converged with economics" to achieve its political goal.

As Zuboff points out, Hannah Arendt's The Origins of Totalitarianism (1951) "was a detailed disclosure and a pioneering attempt to theorize what had just occured." A few years later, in 1954, the political scientist Carl Friedrich wrote that "virtually no one before 1914 anticipated" totalitarianism.

Today, instrumentarianism refers to a yet different kind of threat, one that "moves differently and toward an opposite horizon." It's essentially an economic project, though it "converges with the digital." It works not through "violence" but through "behavioral modification." And it is "best undestood as the precise antithesis of Orwell's Big Brother." Zuboff:

"Instrumentarian power has no interest in our souls or any principle to instruct. There is no training or transformation for spiritual salvation, no ideology against which to judge our actions. It does not demand possession of each person from the inside out. It has no interest in exterminating or disfiguring our bodies and minds in the name of pure devotion. It welcomes data on the behavior of our blood and shit, but it has no interest in soiling itself with our excretions. It has no appetite for our grief, pain, or terror, although it eagerly welcomes the behavioral surplus that leaches from our anguish. It is profoundly and infinitely indifferent to our meanings and motives. Trained on measurable action, it only cares that whatever we do is accessible to its ever-evolving operations of rendition, calculation, modification, monetization, and control."

The behaviorist B. F. Skinner, in his utopian novel Walden Two, envisioned "social equality and dispassionate harmony founded on the viewpoint of the Other-One, the 'organism among organisms,' as the object of 'behavioral engineering.'" The commmunity has laws "derived from a sicence of human behavior," so although it rejects "democratic politics and representative government," it has no need for force.

"Until the rise of surveillance capitalism, the prospect of instrumentarian power was relegated to a gauzy world of dream and delusion. This new species of power follows the logic of Planck, Meyer, and Skinner in the forfeit of freedom for knowledge, but those scientists each failed to anticipate the actual terms of this surrender. The knowledge that now displaces our freedom is proprietary. The knowledge is theirs, but the lost freedom belongs solely to us."

So the digital apparatus, Zuboff says, is not Big Brother (dominating our souls) but Big Other (influencing our behavior).

"Instrumentarian power cultivates an unusual 'way of knowing' that combines the 'formal indifference' of the neoliberal worldview with the observational perspective of radical behaviorism. ... [It] reduces human experience to measurable observable behavior while remaining steadfastly indifferent to the meaning of that experience. I call this new way of knowing radical indifference. It is a form of observation without witness that yields the obverse of an intimate violence political religion and bears an utterly different signature of havoc: the remote and abstracted contempt of impenetrably complex systems and the interests that author them, carrying individuals on a fast-moving current to the fulfillment of others' ends. What passes for social relations and economic exchange now occurs across the medium of this robotized veil of abstraction."

When terrorism exposes a lack of trust, instrumentarian power shows up to promise certainty. It seeks "total information as the ideal condition for machine intelligence" and for "market dominance." We give up society, the real collective life; in its place, enabled by "the resources of the shadow text," we have certainty, "this imagined collective life," in which "freedom is forfeit to others' knowledge."

This pursuit of knowledge is for the sake of privilege and power. As surveillance capitalists increase their knowledge of us, our freedom decreases. Surveillance capitalism is dominating

"the division of learning in society. False consciousness is no longer produced by the hidden facts of class and their relation to production but rather by the hidden facts of instrumentarian power's command over the divison of learning in society as it usurps the rights to answer the essential questions: Who knows? Who decides? Who decides who decides? Power was once identified with the owernship of the means of production, but it is now identified with ownership of the means of behavioral modification that is Big Other."

Pipikism

Naomi Klein wrote: “Philip Roth explored this push and pull in his doppelganger novel Operation Shylock: 'It's too ridiculous to take seriously and too serious to be ridiculous,' he wrote of a duplicate Roth. That sentence has become my mantra during this uncanny period.”

Pipik is Yiddish for bellybutton. To pipik, in Roth's sense, is to reduce something serious to trivial nonsense. But in mocking the serious, one generates new pitfalls: one may fail to take seriously something that does pose a danger and, in its place, scapegoat or threaten a vulnerable group that isn't responsible for the real problem. It's a shifting of perspective, a misunderstanding of the problem, and with it, a misattribution of responsibility.

For example, as Klein explains, “the very idea of treating the pandemic as a portal to something new — something better, greener, and fairer — was being systematically pipiked in the Mirror World by people like my doppelganger. It was getting all mixed up and conflated with the conspiracy talk about how ‘globalist elites’ at the World Economic Forum were trying to harness the recovery for their Great Reset.”

To me, sometimes aspects of the fascist pipiking feel a bit murdery. But that may be an ancestral memory (one that they often deliberately invoke, if sideways). Yet they're usually not aiming for literal mass murder, not in the totalitarian way. Zuboff says that whereas "totalitarianism was bent on the reconstruction of the human species through the dual mechanisms of genocide and the 'engineering of the soul'," now "instrumentarian power...takes us in a sharply different direction. Surveillance capitalists have no interest in murder or the reformation of our souls."

Due to the “constantly expanding sphere of pipikism,” Klein says, it becomes “more difficult to talk” about anything politically serious. So, if "...'ecofascism' is the accurate term to describe the threat," Klein says, "how convenient it is for coalescing fascist forces if the term has been so abused and pipiked that anti-fascists are loath to use it to accurately describe events in the real world." It also repurposes the words to amplify their fascist redirections and reframes. Klein says of one occasion: "I couldn’t see how a serious discussion of actual disaster capitalism could avoid getting blended with truly dangerous anti-vaccination fantasies and outright coronavirus denialism. Pipikism had thwarted me."

Klein:

"When the figure of the buffoon becomes central to public life, the problem is not only that they say foolish things but also that everything they touch becomes foolish, including — especially — the powerful language we need to talk about them and what they are doing. I think of these figures as ‘dumbpelgangers,’ and they pipik so many terms and concepts that they risk leaving us all speechless."

Yet, Klein says,

"we must never surrender...the language of anti-fascism. The true meanings of ‘genocide’ and ‘apartheid’ and ‘Holocaust,’ and the supremacist mindset that makes them all possible. Those words we need, as sharp as possible, to name and combat what is rapidly taking shape in the Mirror World — which is an entire cosmology built around claims of superior bodies, superior immune systems, and superior babies, bankrolled by supplement sales, bitcoin, and prenatal yoga.
It all would be so ridiculous — if it weren’t so serious."

Zuboff has a different way of saying that we have become indifferent to real stuff and instead privilege fake stuff:

"...radical indifference is a permanent invitation to the corruption of the first text. It sustains the pathological division of learning in society by forfeiting the integrity of public knowledge for the sake of the volume and scope of the shadow text. Radical indifference leaves a void where reciprocities once thrived."

'Short Film'

I think that last reflection on pipikism — on the frustrating taunts of an evil that doesn't really seem to come from exactly anywhere, because it isn't about anything so it isn't traceable — is part of what I was going for in my novel, Most Famous Short Film of All Time when I talked about the import of "nothing." "Nothing" can be good or bad. Things presented as unimportant can be quite important.

the car, detail from the book cover of Most Famous Short Film of All Time
Detail from the cover of Short Film. Artist: Cel La Flaca

Who decides?

Here is Zuboff's question:

"Instrumentarian society defines the ultimate institutionalization of a pathological division of learning. Who knows? Who decides? Who decides who decides? * * * [These social principles] ... represent a stark break with the legacies and ideals of the liberal order. Instrumentarian society is a topsy-turvy fun-house-mirror world in which everything that we have cherished is turned upside down and inside out. Pentland doubles down on the illiberality of behavioral economics. In his hands the ideology of human frailty is not merely cause for contempt but a justification for the death of individuality. Self-determination and autonomous moral judgment, generally regarded as the bulwark of civilization, are recast as a threat to collective well-being. Social pressure, well-known to psychologists for its dangerous production of obedience and conformity, is elevated to the highest good as the means to extinguish the unpredictable influences of autonomous thought and moral judgment."

We have "fellow feeling" and "vibrate to one another." We have an "individually sensed inwardness that is the wellspring of personal autonomy and moral judgment, the first-person voice, the will to will, and the sense of an inalienable right to the future tense." But the new intstrumentarianism makes it so

"it is less that we resonate to one another's presence and more that we drown in its inescapability.
Instrumentarianism reimagines society as a hive to be monitored and tuned for guaranteed outcomes, but this tells us nothing of the lived experience of its members. What are the consequences of life lived in the hive, where one is perceived as an 'other' to the surveillance capitalists, designers, and tuners who impose their instruments and methods? How and when do we each become an organism among organisms to ourselves and to one another, and with what result?"

"Extinction is a design feature formalized in the conditions of no exit." Unfortunately, "continuously tightening feedback loops cut off the means of exit, creating impossible levels of anxiety that further drive the loops toward confluence." Exits are important because "every exit is an entrance" and "to exit means to enter the place where a self can be birthed and nurtured. History has a name for that kind of place: sanctuary." While some would ask "the guilt-inducing question 'What have you got to hide?'," we know "the real psychological truth is this: If you've got nothing to hide, you are nothing."

Transphobia, again

I bring this back to transphobia (as I did in my last post). The transphobes, aka the self-described Gender Criticals, are proponents of radical indifference — toward trans people, of course. They sense that the Big Other of surveillance capitalism is taking advantage of them. They don't know where it's coming from. They don't even know what "it" is. They feel victimized by modernity, and tehy try to pin their distress on a scapegoat. Their scapegoat is trans people. They resolve to be pointedly radically indifferent to trans people, which is to say, simultaneously neoliberal and behaviorist, because doing so makes them feel powerful again. They are doing to a minority what has been done to them.

For Zuboff says:

"Instrumentarianism's radical indifference is operationalized in Big Other's dehumanized methods of evaluation that produce equivalence without equality. These methods reduce individuals to the lowest common denominator of sameness — an organism among organisms — despite all teh vital ways in which we are not the same. FRom Big Other's point of view we are strictly Other-Ones: organisms that behave. ... There is no brother here of any kind, big or little, evil or good; there are no family ties, however grim. There is no relationship between Big Other and its otherized objects, just as there was no relationship between B. F. Skinner's 'scientists and subjects.' ... Big Other does not care what we think, feel, or do as long as its millions, billions, and trillions of sensate, actuating, computational eyes and ears can observe, render, datafy, and instrumentalize the vast reservoirs of behavioral surplus that are generated in the galactic uproar of connection and communication.
In this new regime, objectification is the moral milieu in which our lives unfold." ... Big Other poaches are behavior for surplus and leaves behind all the meaning lodged in our bodies, our brains, and our beating hearts, not unlike the monstrous slaughter of elephants for ivory. Forget the cliché that if it's free, 'You are the product.' You are not the product; you are the abandoned carcass. The 'product' derives from the surplus that is ripped from your life."

The larger forces behind what we think of as our modern life with internet — the new market project of surveillance capitalism — is doing this to everyone. Transphobia is a sub-project that has grown to displace blame onto trans people. Transphobia claims that trans people are ripping valuable surplus out of the sexed/gendered lives of cis people — or, as transphobes would prefer to phrase it, "everyone else" —, or, as they'd really, really like to phrase it if they can get away with it, "biological women" and "biological men," since that adjective "biological" seems to infuse one's peopleness with enhanced reality. It's like saying really real people (as contrasted with less real people who don't have any biology, perhaps?). That's why one of transphobia's linguistic projects is to prevent trans people from uttering the word "cis." If we are able to see "cis people" as distinct from "trans people," we see that everyone is biological and that "trans" and "cis" are socially constructed categories, and then we see that there is not really a specifically cisgender surplus that has material value and that trans people can literally steal. By insisting that "trans" is a constructed category but refusing to observe how "cis" is the backside of that construction, they pretend that there is some reified value in sex/gender that dishonest people (i.e., trans people, the thieves) can steal. A question from a trans perspective is: Why would cis lives inherently have, and be the true owners of, this value, and why would trans lives not already have our own version of this value and equally legitimately own what is ours? Phrasing it this way unmasks the essential unfairness of transphobia.

See this in Playboy: "There’s a particular kind of cognitive dissonance involved with being trans and visible online in 2026. Scroll your newsfeed long enough and trans people are treated like abstractions, talking points, threats. Scroll just a little further and those same people are being loved, tipped, subscribed to, flirted with, obsessed over, chased. While anti-trans lawmakers increasingly pass legislation restricting where and how trans people can exist, trans people are also the target of intense romantic and sexual desire." — Trans Porn Is Booming. Trans Rights Are Fading: We asked trans models and creators about the complicated link between desire and politics. Playboy, March 5, 2026

The other books

Shoshana Zuboff. The Age of Surveillance Capitalism: The Fight for a Human Future at the New Frontier of Power. Public Affairs, 2020.

Naomi Klein. Doppelganger: A Trip into the Mirror World. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2023.

See also on this blog: Four books on the strengths and frailties of democracy

almost deadish unhappy person

On surveillance cinema: Go to this page and scroll to the heading "We ask that you refrain from talking about your experience inside the structure" by Sean T. Collins, Jan 19, 2024

Saturday, September 30, 2023

People who are anxious about surveillance capitalism shift blame to trans people

Our ignorance

Regarding our "ignorance" of how the modern internet works, Shoshana Zuboff wrote in 2020 that surveillance capitalists "know things that we cannot know" yet must "conceal their intentions and practices." And: "It is impossible to understand something that has been crafted in secrecy and designed as fundamentally illegible. These systems are intended to ensnare us, preying on our vulnerabilities bred by an asymmetrical division of learning and amplified by our scarcity of time, resources, and support."

Strict behaviorists, like Meyer and Skinner in the 20th century, believed that human freedom was an illusion. There was no free will. For them, regarding "the uncomfortable facts of human ignorance," Zuboff says: "I think of Dickens's Scrooge when he first encounters the doleful, chain-dragging ghost of his deceased partner Jacob Marley and denies the apparition, saying, 'You may be an undigested bit of beef, a blot of mustard, a crumb of cheese, a fragment of an underdone potato.' So it is with freedom: an undigested bit of fear, a crumb of denial that, once metabolized, will dispel the apparition and deliver us to reality. The environment determines behavior, and our ignorance of precisely how it does so is the void that we fill with the fantasy of freedom.'"

The market aspires to "fabricate predictions, which become more valuable as they approach certainty," Zuboff says. Surveillance capitalists need massive, complete data sets, and so they've "hijacked the division of learning in society. They command knowledge from the decisive pinnacle of the social order, where they nourish and protect the shadow text: the urtext of certainty. This is the market net in which we are snared."

Conspiracy theories

In 2023, Naomi Klein explained that many of today's conspiracy theorists (generally on the right wing) are personally motivated by trying to make sense of a profoundly confusing world. Using environmental destruction as an example, Klein says:

"That ecofascist thought would surge in our particular historical moment is, sadly, predictable. We live in a time when having two jobs is no guarantee of affording a home and many of our governments consider bulldozing homeless encampments to be a viable policy solution. Meanwhile, every day brings us closer to a future of climate breakdown that, if it is not slowed and reversed, will surely lead to the culling of large parts of our and other species, hitting the most vulnerable first and worst. The process is already well underway. Being alive in a knife-edge moment like this, being forced to be complicit in it, while our so-called leaders fail so miserably to act, unavoidably generates all kinds of morbid symptoms. Inevitably, people reach for narratives to make sense of this reality."

There's a common narrative in which some nameless "they" are trying to control us through vaccines, 5G, and so on. "Snide" comments from those who are left-leaning tend to be "sublimated into ironic humor, like 'Wait until they hear about cell phones.'" Klein reminds us: Cell phones are exactly what the conspiracy theorists are trying to figure out. She explains:

"They know all about cell phones. They just don’t know what to do about cell phones (or smart speakers or search histories or shadow banning or email and social media metadata...). And neither, it seems, does anyone else, including those in power, who are patently unwilling to rein in what the Harvard professor Shoshana Zuboff has called “surveillance capitalism.” And [Naomi] Wolf, with her 'Five Freedoms' campaign and her calls for anti-vax civil disobedience, is giving her followers something to do. She is telling them that it’s not too late to get their privacy, and their freedoms, back."

Transphobia

In my view, this is also where a lot of transphobia comes from. Certain modern forces are taking advantage of the general population and, to use Zuboff's phrase, they are indeed "crafted in secrecy and designed as fundamentally illegible" — in response to which, some people, rather than trying to understand surveillance capitalism which pragmatically can't be understood, shift blame to transgender people as if we (trans people) were mascots and puppetmasters for some inscrutable self-interest and for incomprehensibility itself.

The books

Shoshana Zuboff. The Age of Surveillance Capitalism: The Fight for a Human Future at the New Frontier of Power. Public Affairs, 2020.

Naomi Klein. Doppelganger: A Trip into the Mirror World. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2023.

weird little Christmas elf pillow

Image of elf ornament from Wikimedia Commons. Taken by Jelene Morris. Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license.

"An understanding of technology and nature is the same, as technology is made by nature, with raw materials, AI seen as an alien mind but to the same extent it’s a reflection of us. For a revolutionary request is the need of transparency, as state and church collapse, we need political and AI tech collapse, where AI is not the bad cop who co-plays in the march of tech fascism – because right now it gives me the lensherre ick, and techno is so much more fun if you are not adding feudalism. So, fingers crossed we don’t end up in a neofeudalistic barbarian reality, because we suddenly saw ourselves marching for infrastructural sovereignty even though we did not have a choice and got AI-force-fed. * * * I do believe we live in an imitation of the Middle Ages in a neo-medieval late-stage capitalistic Chthulucene. The lord-peasant relation topped with sparkles emoji crumble and digital egregor energy, even my freaking engagement ring is medieval. Crungus and Loab, in bestiary manner, gives a chill down one’s spine, as an alert or a random generative image saying every living thing has its own special meaning – we can debate about the living. So many monsters in that black box."

— Sabine Wedege, The Shoggoth in the Chthulucene: Using Magic to Understand Modern Tech, IDOART, May 23, 2026. In old Norwegian, "lensherre" was the supreme lord, often the king. There's a footnote to "egregor" which explains: "A non-physical entity that arises from collective thoughts and emotions (concept in occult traditions)."

Friday, September 29, 2023

Atlas Network: Pursuing oil profits

Important ideas from an investigative article earlier this month in the New Republic: Meet the Shadowy Global Network Vilifying Climate Protesters

Background

In 1955, Antony Fisher founded a U.K.-based think tank called the Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA). Funded by corporations whose identities they didn't disclose, they distributed articles to universities that supported the corporations' interests. The IEA "help[ed] spread conservative free-market ideology in British politics throughout the 1960s and ’70s" and grew into "a global network of more than 500 member think tanks advocating for 'free market' policies."

In 1981, he founded the Atlas Network, which "initially only included the first dozen or so think tanks Fisher had helped to found himself." He then set his sights on other countries, "particularly in Latin America, where oil executives were concerned about leftist movements. One of the first investments Atlas made was in Venezuela, where it funded the launch of the Center for the Dissemination of Economic Information, or CEDICE, in 1984." The Atlas Network "quickly expanded to include hundreds of like-minded member organizations, including all the Koch-affiliated think tanks in the U.S. (The Cato Institute, the Heartland Institute, the Heritage Foundation, and the American Legislative Exchange Council—some of the most influential forces shaping U.S. conservative politics—are all members.)" Today the Atlas Network is "a global network of more than 500 member think tanks advocating for 'free market' policies."

For more, see this book, mentioned in the New Republic article:

In 2018

The New Republic goes on to explain:

"When [Alejandro] Chafuen left his position as Atlas Network president in 2018, he went on to run one of the most prominent Atlas Network member think tanks: the U.S.-based Acton Institute, which has long pushed a Christian-flavored brand of climate denial. Acton also incubated the Tennessee-based Cornwall Alliance, an association of Evangelical think tanks with close links to another Atlas member, the Heritage Foundation. In a 12-part DVD series called Resisting the Green Dragon, released in 2010, the Cornwall Alliance described environmentalism as 'spiritual deception' and warned of 'dangerous environmental extremism.'"

This kind of rhetoric is exactly what we see today in countries moving swiftly to criminalize environmental and climate protest. While industries and governments around the world had plenty of their own reasons for categorizing environmentalists as extremists separate from the think tank influence, Atlas Network organizations have capitalized on that framing for decades. In recent years, they’ve packaged it in ways that have been turned into anti-protest legislation.

Today

Today, the Atlas Network organizations are portraying Indigenous-led environmental protests — in places like Guatemala, the U.S., Canada, and Australia — as terrorism.

This is also happening in Germany. For example:

In 2014, Frank Schäffler, a hard-right member of the German Parliament, founded a think tank, "Prometheus: Das Freiheitsinstitut," that joined the Atlas Network. Since early 2022, Schäffler "began describing them [the German climate organization Letzte Generation (Last Generation)] as terrorists, calling the group a 'criminal organization' and publicly demanding it be investigated for organized crime. Media outlets, including conservative publisher Welt and the more mainstream Der Spiegel, soon echoed Schäffler’s framing."

In early 2023, young Letzte Generation activists "obstructed streets in an effort to draw attention to the German government’s inaction on climate," per the New Republic. The police response was unusually harsh: "A young woman, with her hand glued to the asphalt, was ripped off the road by her hair; a young man was run over by a truck driver; a passerby punched protesters and was cheered on." A few months later, in May, police raided the homes of these activists across Germany and froze their bank accounts, alleging "the group was 'a criminal organization that was fundraising for the purpose of committing further criminal action.' It was almost exactly the response to Last Generation that Schäffler had recommended."

The Atlas Network has succeeded in persuading media outlets to frame climate activism within

"stories that discuss whether it’s 'appropriate' to throw tomato soup at the display case of a famous painting or glue oneself to a road — and whether these tactics endear climate activists to the public or not — rather than on what the protesters are actually trying to accomplish.

Media Matters’ analysis found that fewer than half of U.S. media stories on climate protest included anything about the scientific basis for climate change or the political stalemate driving the surge in protests. Meanwhile, the study found that Fox News has run four times the combined coverage of its competitors CNN (27 segments) and MSNBC (9 segments); all of the network’s 144 segments on the topic have painted climate protesters as dangerous radicals."

Source

Meet the Shadowy Global Network Vilifying Climate Protesters For decades, the Atlas Network has used its reach and influence to spread conservative philosophy—and criminalize climate protest. Amy Westervelt and Geoff Dembicki, New Republic, September 12, 2023. The article says: "Neither the Atlas Network nor any of the other member think tanks mentioned in this piece replied to requests for comment."

oil rig on fire

Thursday, September 28, 2023

USA: The Kids Online Safety Act (KOSA) is anti-LGBTQ

"The Department of Commerce’s National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) sent out a request for public comment on Thursday calling for parents, educators and other interested parties to write in and share their concerns and “best practices” around internet usage of kids and teens."
* * *
The request urged parents, educators, caregivers, technologists, advertisers and online creators to submit comments. To comment, go to the regulations.gov website, search for NTIA-2023-008 and select 'comment now.'"
— "Got an idea for protecting kids online? You can now take action" (unpaywalled gift link) The federal government wants you to weigh in on potential laws and guidelines around social media and young people" Tatum Hunter, September 28, 2023

On ntia.gov, you can see their press release:
NTIA Seeks Comment on Protecting Kids Online which links to their request for comment:
Kids Online Health and Safety Request for Comment
It gives the same instruction for commenting.

Unfortunately, the comment page doesn't seem to be available yet on regulations.gov as of 11:30 a.m. Eastern on Sept. 28.

Previously:

"KOSA: A Nationwide Anti-Trans/LGBTQ+ Bill in All but Name" And What You Can Do to Stop It, Julia Serano, Medium, September 13, 2023. At least at the moment (Sept. 28), it appears this isn't paywalled. If you hit Medium's paywall, try the same post on Substack.

Serano says:

"...the language regarding what constitutes 'harm' is written in an extremely broad way, applying to anything that might impact 'anxiety, depression, eating disorders, substance use disorders, and suicidal behaviors' in minors.

And who gets to decide whether minors are being negatively impacted in these ways? State attorneys general. You know, people like Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey, who earlier this year announced an emergency rule banning gender-affirming care for most trans people of all ages. Or Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, who last year declared that gender-affirming care for minors constitutes 'child abuse,' leaving trans children susceptible to being removed from their parents’ custody."

Serano quotes Senator Marsha Blackburn admitting that this is KOSA's purpose. Blackburn referred to "protecting minor children from the transgender in this culture and that influence" in the same breath with KOSA when asked for "the top issue that conservatives should be taking action on."

Serano adds: "And it’s not just LGBTQ+ content that is likely to be targeted. Republican state attorneys general could also target information about abortion, or 'CRT,' or basically anything they oppose that can be flimsily tied to children’s mental health issues."

Serano's call to action:

"...contact your senators and representatives ASAP and tell them you strongly oppose the bill. You can do so via the website StopKosa.com — just enter your information and they’ll send a letter to your lawmakers or provide you with what you need to call them yourself. The Electric Frontier Foundation has set up a similar webform."

Jude Ellison Doyle says:

"..discussions are being held about how to make the Internet safer — but those conversations don’t hinge on finding legislative means of stamping out Internet-crowdsourced violence. They hinge on stamping out trans people.

The Kid’s Online Safety Act, a bill with broad bipartisan support and the vocal backing of Joe Biden, is nominally intended to shield children from “harmful content” or content that encourages self-harm (like, say, pro-ana content that encourages eating disorders). In fact, conservative lawmakers, including Senator Marsha Blackburn, are already celebrating the fact that KOSA will allow them to ban content by and about transgender people."

KiwiFarms Went Down. Now Everything is KiwiFarms. It’s been a year since the famous hate forum went down, and the Internet is more hostile than ever to marginalized groups. Jude Ellison S. Doyle, Medium, September 7, 2023

"U.S. Senator: 'Kids Online Safety Act' will target trans content" The lead sponsor stated in a video that it will be used to 'protect minor children from the transgender in our culture'. Erin Reed. LA Blade. September 3, 2023.

"Congress Is Pushing An Online Safety Bill Supported By Anti-LGBTQ Groups" Advocates say the Kids Online Safety Act (KOSA) will be weaponized to censor LGBTQ content. Janus Rose, Vice, August 3, 2023

"Senators revive kids online safety push as states bypass Washington." (subscriber paywall) Analysis by Cristiano Lima with research by David DiMolfetta. Washington Post. May 3, 2023

Kids Online Safety Act would target trans content, senator confirms "There's this giant censorship machine that also is privacy invasive." Anna Iovine, Mashable, September 4, 2023

The Internet Is About to Get a Lot Worse Happy Dancing #109, Charlie Jane Anders, August 22, 2023.

"Elizabeth Warren Just Backed an ‘Online Safety’ Bill That Will Harm LGBTQ Youth": The Kids Online Safety Act has gained support from right-wing groups that want to crack down on LGBTQ content, and now Senator Elizabeth Warren. Evan Greer. Vice, October 6, 2023.

Heads up

A proposed Minnesota Kids Code for internet restrictions. Oregon recently suffered a similar proposal.

Florida House Approves Bill Banning Social Media For Kids Under 16 The bill, which passed the House in a vote of 106 to 13, will now go to Florida's GOP-controlled Senate for a final vote. Sebastian Murdock, HuffPost, Jan 25, 2024

the word NO

KOSA

Back in play, January 2024.

Does the government care about your internet privacy?

"The National Security Agency has been buying Americans’ web browsing data from commercial data brokers without warrants, intelligence officials disclosed in documents made public by a US senator Thursday.

The purchases include information about the websites Americans visit and the apps that they use, said Oregon Democratic Sen. Ron Wyden, releasing newly unclassified letters he received from the Pentagon in recent weeks confirming the sales.

The disclosures are the latest evidence that government agencies routinely buy sensitive information about Americans from commercial marketplaces that they would otherwise be required to obtain via court order."

The NSA buys Americans’ internet data, newly released documents show Brian Fung, CNN, January 26, 2024

This has been a rotten bill since the word go. When I was a reporter, I had several Dem Congressional aides and tech lobbyists call me — some berating me — telling me I had become an activist for saying so. I hadn't, the bill is just a speech nightmare, and its primary target is trans people.

[image or embed]

— A.D.D. Sulzberger (@bencollins.bsky.social) Jul 30, 2024 at 6:24 PM

Make sure you have the most updated version of the bill (Oct 19, 2024)

@warren.senate.gov how many times do we need to explain to you that the aim for KOSA has been to erase queer and trans people from the internet - this has been VERY clear from the start!

[image or embed]

— Fight for the Future (@fightforthefuture.org) December 10, 2025 at 4:46 PM

Op-Ed: With KOSA, Elizabeth Warren is Betraying the Trans Youth She Claims to Protect Evan Greer writes for EITM: "KOSA’s re-emergence comes during a moment of existential crisis for the Democratic party." Evan Greer, Erin in the Morning, Jan 12, 2026

Congress Is Considering Abolishing Your Right to Be Anonymous Online: The bipartisan push to remove anonymity from the internet is ushering in an era of unprecedented mass surveillance and censorship. Taylor Lorenz, The Intercept, March 5 2026

In case you missed it

You Can’t Pull a Lever to Write Your Book (and 69 Other Lessons)

Everything I know about writing a complicated and difficult book On November 4, the Book Bazaar on Twitch aired my 52-minute recorded v...