Thursday, June 29, 2023

Jordan Peterson, intellectual dark web

Who is Jordan Peterson?

Lisa Sugiura's book The Incel Rebellion: The Rise of the Manosphere and the Virtual War Against Women (2021) is open access.

When Canada proposed a nondiscrimination bill for gender identity and expression, Jordan Peterson opposed it, claiming that if everyone has to respect everyone else's pronouns, there's no free speech. That's why he's famous today.

Sugiura explains that the "rejection of identity politics" is behind the so-called "intellectual dark web." These are academics who "view themselves as dissidents and mavericks and position themselves as truth tellers," principally Peterson, now a bestselling author with a "subscription-only, ‘anti-censorship’ website called Thinkspot" he launched in 2019. Peterson is

"notorious for his seething critiques against feminism and ‘cultural marxism’ – the (conspiracy) theory that Marxist Jewish academics at the Frankfurt School in the 1930s are responsible for devising the ideas underpinning multiculturalism and critical theory – essentially embedding Marxist ideals into cultural values (Neiwert, 2020). According to opponents such as Peterson, the influence of cultural Marxism is so significant that it dominates contemporary academia and culture, with feminism being one of the products of this duplicitous cabal. ... [His books] normalise and rationalise the patriarchial social order..."

He says there's no "gender wage gap" and he cites "bunk statistics" on that, Sugiura says. He bases his arguments on "gender role stereotypes – that women aren’t in high-pressure leadership roles because they don’t want them as it would be a conflict with women's 'agreeable' nature. Peterson also validated incel violence as a means to counter rejection, in the New York Times in regard to Minassian’s Toronto attack – 'he was angry at God because women were rejecting him. The cure for that is enforced monogamy. That's actually why monogamy emerges'," Sugiura writes of Peterson's comments. Peterson later claimed he hadn't meant to endorse the incel demand to provide them with women for their use, but rather was explaining the norm of monogamy.

Annika Brockschmidt tweets: Jordan Peterson, rape apologist. When I didn’t think he could sink any lower, he just keeps digging. He truly has become the go-to guru for the modern incel who 'likes to think of himself as a bit of a philosopher'

Peterson is saying that men won't defend assaulted women unless they think of the woman as their property. That's the only way — according to him — they can empathize or otherwise believe that her rights and dignity are important.


Emily Qureshi-Hurst tweets: It fills me with despair that for many people ~this fucking guy~ is the only reference point for an academic. His use of concepts is sloppy, his arguments are lazy, he is deliberately inflammatory, and almost all the time he's just plain wrong.

Peterson is saying:

"Let's say you have a non-standard gender identity. What the hell are other people supposed to do about that? ...if I don't know whether you're male or female, what the hell should I do with you? You don't know, because you don't know what the rules are. And so the simplest thing for me to do is just not do anything with you. The simplest thing for me to do is just go find someone else who's a hell of a lot less trouble."
nihility tweets: bro literally can only be a misogynist

Update: This is what he's up to, June 27, 2023.

In 2018, David Brooks wrote: 'My friend Tyler Cowen argues that Jordan Petrson is the most influential public intellectual in the Western world...' On June 27, 2023, Peterson tweeted: 'Call me cis to my face and see what happens.' Ari Drennen responds in 2023: 'Jordan Peterson needs to log off and clean his room'

July 3, 2023. He's saying that anyone who categorizes transgender people with the genders in which we live or with which we identify is someone who is very far from "deserving any politeness."

Jordan Peterson tweets July 3, 2023: 
Trans 'women' are men
And all the woke whining about 'misinformation'
Which in this case is just the simplest, most basic and obvious truth
Won't change that
To hell with you 
You bloody manipulative narcissists 
You've gone way beyond
Deserving any politeness
Ari Drennen @AriDrennen This is without a doubt the worst poem I have ever read

August 2023

Book reviewers complained after he took positive-sounding phrases from their overwhelmingly negative reviews and used them for his book jacket.

October 2023

Apparently taking a page from Peterson's playbook, J.K. Rowling (then 3.5 years into her own transphobic Twitter campaign) tweeted that she'd "happily do two years [in prison] if the alternative is compelled speech and forced denial of the reality and importance of sex." It isn't an innovative framing. Peterson has been on this horse for years.

Further reading

In one video I examined, he says stereotypes are necessary. See: "Helen Joyce in conversation with Jordan Peterson: That Transphobic Peterson/Joyce Video" (Medium; paywalled)

See also: "When you claim that experts don't know their stuff" (on Medium)

Tuesday, June 27, 2023

The 'Intellectual Dark Web' isn't being silenced

Lisa Sugiura's book The Incel Rebellion: The Rise of the Manosphere and the Virtual War Against Women (2021) is open access.

female baseball player points finger at referee in old-style black-and-white photo

Sugiura explains the Intellectual Dark Web's complaint against what they call "grievance studies," modern academic pursuits that they see as driven by biased political agendas:

"In 2017, three scholars linked with the intellectual dark web – James Lindsay, Helen Pluckrose and Peter Boghossian, who describe themselves as left-leaning liberals and seemingly have more time at their disposal than most academics – coordinated a scam against gender, queer, critical race, masculinities studies, amongst others nicknamed Sokal Squared. Heavily influenced by the Sokal Hoax, the ploy involved the creation of 20 fake papers using fashionable jargon submitted to various journals in these fields, with the aim of exposing ridiculous conclusions."

Alt-right figure Milo Yiannopoulos pushes the envelope with his overtly antisemitic and racist comments. Along with Jordan Peterson, he claims his right to speak is being curtailed:

"Yiannopoulos rationalised his comments, emphasising his homosexuality and alleging that he is a victim of child abuse, as well as referring to his Jewish mother and being raised Jewish...In 2019, he was permanently banned along with other far right commentators – Alex Jones, Laura Loomer, Louis Farrakhan and Paul Nehlen, from Twitter and Facebook for breaching their hate speech rules."

In March 2021, Yiannopoulos declared he is now ‘ex-gay’ and his husband is now his housemate, Sugiura said.

They aren't being silenced

Sugiura explains this:

"Loud claims about being silenced from people with significant political and institutional power demonstrate that the exact opposite is occurring. If they were truly silenced, as those who are oppressed, then we would not hear or see them, and they certainly would not have the wealth of access to the public consciousness in the manner they do. As Sara Ahmed so eloquently puts it 'whenever people keep being given a platform, or whenever people speak endlessly about being silenced, you not only have a performative contradiction; you are witnessing a mechanism of power'. Claiming to be silenced amplifies and distributes reactionary forms of speech generating outrage. This is how figures such as Jordan Peterson and Milo Yiannopoulos have created platforms, by alleging they have none." [emphasis mine]

By the way:

"There is a current loophole within the proposed law, that protections for free speech could result in perverse outcomes, where a user could complain that legal racist, sexist, homophobic or transphobic content has been removed and therefore should be re-uploaded on a platform."

However

On August 23, 2023, an Ontario court upheld a November 2022 order from the College of Psychologists of Ontario which said Peterson must take social media training to improve his professionalism in his public statements.

Also: Climate change denial

"Magatte Wade, who heads an internal Atlas project called the Center for African Prosperity, frequently cites de Soto as an inspiration for her take on Africa and climate change. In multiple op-eds over the past few years, and in an interview this year with Canadian professor and right-wing figurehead Jordan Peterson, Wade, who was born in Senegal but moved to Germany when she was 7, describes climate activists as the new colonialists, arguing that climate action will keep Africans poor and deprive them of access to energy. Wade often depicts those who would deny the continent its current fossil fuel boom as out-of-touch elitists and regularly claims that climate action will kill a billion Africans—all while refusing to engage with the fact that African climate activists are being arrested at an alarming rate."
— Meet the Shadowy Global Network Vilifying Climate Protesters For decades, the Atlas Network has used its reach and influence to spread conservative philosophy—and criminalize climate protest. Amy Westervelt and Geoff Dembicki, New Republic, September 12, 2023.

On which point, I encourage you to read my article: "When you claim that experts don't know their stuff", about Jordan Peterson's January 2022 appearance on the Joe Rogan podcast in which he claimed that climate scientists have no idea what they're talking about because "climate" doesn't refer to anything in particular. For $5 you can read this article and millions of others on Medium for a whole month.

Listened to an NPR story this morning about mass child starvation in Senegal without a single mention of Elon Musk, the guy who gleefully created the conditions for the mass starvation

— Denny Carter (@dennycarter.bsky.social) June 13, 2026 at 7:27 AM

Pro-Trump podcasters are divided over Trump's immigration and deportation policies: Figures like Joe Rogan are facing backlash from some in conservative media after calling Trump’s mass deportations “insane” and “barbaric”. Noah Dowe & Ben Van Bloem. Media Matters. 11/07/25

20th-century beginnings of the 'men's rights movement'

Lisa Sugiura's book The Incel Rebellion: The Rise of the Manosphere and the Virtual War Against Women (2021) is open access.

surreal painting of two people in a boat flying in the sky
Čeština: Nebeská etapa, 2007. Art by Eugene Ivanov.
Creative Commons license


Originally, what did 'men's rights' mean?

To start with, Sugiura considers movements like Fathers for Justice (FFJ), whose

"primary focus...is actual men's problems rather than espousing vitriol against women, progressiveness and feminism. FFJ is concerned with paternal rights and ensuring that fathers have access to their children when relationships break down, when Criminal Justice Systems entrenched in sexist, conservative ideals ordinarily operate in favour of the mother. In this respect, the continuation of traditional gender roles, the desire and ideal of other groups in the manosphere, marginalises men and devalues their status as parents."

Some men feel disappointed because they were somehow — overtly, by individuals? implicitly, by systems? — led to believe they'd be more powerful and successful than they are.

"Pleck (1974, 1995) attempted to navigate this complexity by asserting that though they hold institutional power in patriarchal societies, most men do not actually feel powerful, creating a further conundrum for men to reconcile with – why do they not feel powerful when they are supposed to?"

An early idea of a "male mystique" and recognition that some men want custody of their kids:

"Marc Feigan Fasteau’s The Male Machine discussed the emotional impacts of restrictive masculinity, borrowing from Betty Friedan’s The Feminine Mystique. Feigan Fasteau (1974, p. xiv) wrote that men's 'denial of dependency ... and emotions leads to silence and the creation of a male mystique'. Feigan Fasteau is also famous for his egalitarian marriage with Brenda Feigan Fasteau, a feminist lawyer who co-founded the Women’s Action Alliance with Gloria Steinem, and with whom he set up a law partnership, representing gender cases such as fathers who sought custody in divorce cases."

Later, especially "pre-web in the 1980s or as part of Web 1.0 from the 1990s to 2000s," men's rights organizations focused on political issues like whether family law (child custody, visitation, and child support) favored "women's interests" and whether that was a legislative attack that was part of "feminism's perceived attack on fatherhood" (Gotell & Dutton, 2016; Kimmel, 2017; Maddison, 1999).

"The previous ‘feminist hero’, Warren Farrell, had taken umbrage against NOW's stance in divorce cases, in declaring their support of providing child custody to the main caregiver, who was usually the mother, and having been through a divorce himself, came to the conclusion that feminists were more interested in power than in equality, a view that was being echoed by many more men. The disillusionment with feminism continued to escalate with the growth of women entering the workforce."

Saturday, June 24, 2023

Republican support for gay relationships dropped 15% last year

Quote:

"Yet Christian extremists would have you believe that LGBTQ people are the 'groomers.' That simply being LGBTQ in public is a threat to children. They say this even as church after church across multiple denominations are exposed for covering up and enabling decades of abuse.

Unfortunately, it appears that these same Christian extremists are making inroads. Following the Religious Right's anti-LGBTQ 'grooming' narrative, more and more Americans consider LGBTQ relationships "immoral," finds a new Gallup poll. Today, practically all groups are less tolerant, but Republicans are the demographic where support has eroded the most. Their support for same-sex relationships has dropped 15 percentage points over the past year, with a majority of them now against LGBTQ couples."

— Atheist News, email newsletter from American Atheists, June 24, 2023

The second link goes to a Business Insider article that says: "In the poll last month, the latest edition of a survey that Gallup conducts annually, just 41% of Republicans said gay or lesbian relations were morally acceptable, a 15-percentage-point drop from 2022. ... Democratic approval also fell to 79% from 85%. ... The sharp drop in support among some Americans follows an especially aggressive year of anti-LGBTQ rhetoric and politics. ... Last year, the crisis-monitoring group ACLED found that right-wing extremists had held at least 55 protests explicitly targeting LGBTQ people, with the rise in such actions correlating with a spike in violence against them."


I also recommend James Finn's essay, "Support for Same-Sex Marriage Falls as Right Intensifies ‘War on Trans’: Let me tell you why that matters to me. I hope it matters to you." It's a 7-minute read on Medium.

old-style photo of person posing in a leotard

Unpack the court!

Quote:

"The Constitution does not limit the Supreme Court to nine justices. In fact, Congress has changed the size of the Court seven times. It should do so again in order to remedy the extreme partisanship of today’s Supreme Court.

Some may decry this as 'court packing,' but the real court-packing occurred when Senate Republicans refused to even consider a Democratic nominee to the Supreme Court on the fake pretext that it was too close to the 2016 election, but then confirmed a Republican nominee just days before the 2020 election.

Rather than allow Republicans to continue exploiting the system, expanding the Supreme Court would actually unpack the court."

— Robert Reich, Three reforms to restore trust in the Supreme Court: On the anniversary of Dobbs, and the revelations about Alito, Substack, June 24, 2023

dinosaur skeletons arranged in a museum as if they were battling

In this story, I see Trump expect that the Supreme Court will be partisan, and he complains that it isn't partisan enough, insofar as a 6–3 majority ought to ensure he always gets his way but sometimes he loses his case. Trump Lobs Extraordinary Attack At The Supreme Court Over Tariff Ruling: The president also lashed out against a federal judge who dealt a blow to the Justice Department's probe into Jerome Powell. Marita Vlachou, HuffPost, Mar 16, 2026

Friday, June 23, 2023

Transphobia by Alex Jones of InfoWars

Knowledge Fight is a podcast primarily covering Alex Jones of InfoWars infamy. These episodes mention transphobia in the brief written description of the episode.

  • #16: February 24, 2017 - "Does Alex want to kill trans people?"
  • #127: February 8, 2018 - "...the painful episode of The Alex Jones Show from Feb. 8, 2018...lashing out aggressively at the trans community."
  • #575: July 4, 2021 - "check in on the Baby Bigot section of his website to see what kind of content Alex is associating himself with these days. (Content warning: transphobia, homophobia...)"
  • #643: January 28, 2022 - "In this installment, Alex loves the Canadian trucker convoy, gets deeply transphobic (probably because of Minnie Mouse)"
  • #658: It's Pretty Easy Being Greene - "this episode does cover a fair amount of transphobic territory"
  • #668: April 8, 2022 - "In this installment, Alex gets transphobic, takes some calls, and compares the Globalists to cartoon bugs."
  • #795: April 4-5, 2023 - "...see how Alex covered Trump getting arrested. As it turns out, Alex got really transphobic..."
wicked witch of the west from the wizard of oz: let me introduce you to my evil plan

Wednesday, June 21, 2023

2020 "Open Letter on Justice and Open Debate" in Harper's

Aidan Comerford tweets: In 2020, a group of prominent writers, including @jk_rowling, signed an open letter to @Harpers defending free speech and argument against 'reprisal' for 'bad ideas,' and I guarantee you not one of them will say anything about this.

Aidan went on to say:

"Prominent people who speak about the important of "free speech" rarely, if ever, mean free speech for the proles. "Free speech," generally means THEY want the right to say hurtful, dangerous, frankly stupid things about minorities, without consequence or censure. It's a ruse. t's ridiculous that a useful word that simply means "not trans" would be banned on this platform, especially given that people can call trans people all manner of transphobic slurs on here without consequence now. Calling trans people "troons" etc. isn't a "bad idea," it's hate speech that increases transphobia, which destroys trans people's lives. Transphobic hate speech leads to dead trans people. Saying that non-trans people are non-trans doesn't lead to dead non-trans people. And just look at how clunky that last sentence of that last tweet was, because, now, we don't have the freedom to use a useful word in debate. ... We generally agree on what words are dangerous slurs. We know those slurs have rung in the ears of minority people as they are beaten to death by bigots. That, alone, is a powerful argument to suspend people from social media who use slurs to attack those who "lack power." To ban people for using an elegant word that means "not trans" is frankly farcical. People who aren't trans don't "lack power." They actually have huge power over trans people's lives, and trans people often have to prostate themselves for a modicum of empathy in return."
Frankie Huang, Sept 24, 2023, on Twitter: I want to read about how bigots harness being 'cancelled' by marginalized folks to trigger a surge of support from fellow bigots that lead to increases in wealth & standing? I’m interested in how we get tricked into dishing up outrage that power the 'post-cancellation comeback'

What was the Harper's Letter? Learn more.

These stories may be paywalled. If they are, you know what to do! ($upport the writers)

David Palumbo-Liu
Jul 8, 2020
Why “Justice” and “Open Debate” Don’t Fit Together in Trump’s America Why “Justice” and “Open Debate” Don’t Fit Together in Trump’s America “A Letter on Justice and Open Debate” (aka “The Letter”) published in Harper’s online edition of 7 July 2020, has become the latest, and perhaps worst, instance of celebrities thoughtlessly piling on to sign a ridiculous, ill-conceived, attention-getting “Open…

Aaron Huertas
Jul 8, 2020
How Did the Organizers of the Harper’s Letter Mislead Some of the Signers? (It’s About Ethics in Open Letters) Harper’s “A Letter on Justice and Open Debate” has gotten a lot of attention and there are some fine responses out there already, including this very funny one. But I wanted to dive into a few specific claims about the letter itself, who signed it and whatever (possibly odd!) process…

Holly Lyn Walrath in Write Weird
Jul 8, 2020
Erasure of the Harper’s Cancel Culture Letter “A Letter on Justice and Open Debate” —

Cassidy Routh
Jul 9, 2020
Harper’s Letter on Justice and Open Debate Explained Hi, if you’re like me, you had a hard time reading the infamous letter because it was so pompous you rolled your eyes after each sentence and constantly lost your place. In this rewrite, I skip many of the parts where the signees try to save face (i.e. “protests are…

Julie Hotard
Jul 7, 2020
Response to A Letter on Justice and Open Debate There’s been much ado about a letter than appeared in Harper’s today. A Letter on Justice and Open Debate | Harper's Magazine July 7, 2020 The below letter will be appearing in the Letters section of the magazine's October issue. We welcome…harpers.org It seems everyone just loves the idea of free speech — even Nazis — as long as one doesn’t say precisely what one is talking about. I certainly hope the signatories to the letter will read some of…

Kali Tal
Jul 8, 2020
Thoughts on “A Letter on Justice and Open Debate,” JK Rowling, and Caping for Inequality in the… Thoughts on “A Letter on Justice and Open Debate,” JK Rowling, and Caping for Inequality in the Guise of “Freedom of Speech” About 150 public intellectuals and literary figures recently signed a letter, published in Harpers, that protests the “constriction” of the “free exchange of information and ideas.” While on…

Faith O. Potts
Jul 13, 2020
The Harper’s Letter is an Example of Privileged Individuals Exaggerating the Power of the Marginalized Harper’s Magazine released “A Letter on Justice and Open Debate” — but its message is incredibly vague, and many of the 150 signatories have a history of oppressive discourse — On Tuesday, Harper’s Magazine released a new letter — “A Letter on Justice and Open Debate” — that includes 150 signatures by a variety of writers, journalists, and academics, all of whom have semi-prominent to extremely prominent platforms. The letter starts out sounding positive — “Our cultural institutions are facing…

Alex Steullet
Jul 8, 2020
What if Cancel Culture Were Just Our New Reality? To be honest, I never really believed that cancel culture was a thing. Most of those complaining seemed to be privileged elites being denied insane salaries and prestigious positions for legitimate reasons. While I’m a firm believer in freedom of speech, I don’t believe in...

Keaton Weiss
Jul 16, 2020
Calling Out Bad Actors Doesn’t Hurt Open Debate: A Response to the Harper’s Letter “A Letter on Justice and Open Debate” was recently published in Harper’s Magazine and co-signed by dozens of writers, authors, and academics from all corners of the political spectrum.

Stacy Becker
Jul 18, 2020
A Rewrite of “A Letter on Just and Open Debate” Why oh why do we believe that debate is good for society? — Have you read “A Letter on Justice and Open Debate”? It set off a firestorm of opinion about whose voices the authors were privileging. The letter

Rashmee Roshan Lall
Jul 15, 2020
What is the deal with ‘woke’ culture and writing letters? A battle of letters is under way on the broad and bitterly contested theme of “justice and open debate” and a truce seems unlikely anytime

Though Ron DeSantis in 2023 said the word "woke" seven times in less than a half-minute, Donald Trump said: “I don’t like the term woke. Half the people can’t define it; they don’t know what it is.” (This juxtaposition was pointed out by Lawrence B. Glickman.)

The New York Times Pitchbot is a parody account on Twitter that jokes about NYT headlines that aren't but should be. In this tweet, it is claiming victory for a successful prediction.

Sept 4, 2023 tweet from New York Times pitchbot: How it started. How it's going.
Joke headline, proposed July 19, 2020: The Cancelling of the American Mind by George Packer and Andrew Sullivan
Greg Lukianoff tweets: Nice surprise shout out from the NYTimes for my forthcoming book The Canceling of the American Mind, with co-author Rikki Schlott and foreword by Jon Haidt!

See here. One of the signers of the Harper's Letter, recognizing that it was "a cause of the right" (that is, right-wing), is in 2020 calling for NYPD to arrest faculty members who are participating in a nonviolent political protest.

Caitlin Flanagan a couple years ago:

[image or embed]

— Dave Levitan (@davelevitan.bsky.social) Apr 23, 2024 at 3:43 PM

Exactly, these ghouls spent years defending racists and transphobes by saying that it had nothing to do with the content of their speech, they simply had a content-neutral dedication to free expression. They were lying! They agreed with the far-right views and were too chickenshit to say so.

[image or embed]

— Michael Hobbes (@michaelhobbes.bsky.social) Apr 24, 2024 at 5:00 AM

We have two sets of speech rules in this country: one for the far right, which must be protected in case they turn their wrath on others, and one for everyone else, who are subject to the immediate punitive power of the state for any reason or no reason at all

— jesse (@jesseltaylor.bsky.social) Apr 26, 2024 at 6:22 AM

One way of looking at so-called cancel culture:

"'Cancel Culture' was a reaction to Trump’s victory in 2016 and was a consumer movement. As the walls of the Neoliberal economy closed in, many people were left to decide who could participate in the economy and began sorting their consumer decisions through a moralistic lens. In other words, there was only so much pie and the choice was made to decide who got part of the pie based on their behaviors. This wasn’t political. It was a consumer choice, which Neoliberalism has rendered as one of the only means of actually asserting power." (Jared Yates Sexton, Nov 25, 2024)

Peek behind the paywall. (This was in response to the Harper's Letter.) theracket.news/p/illiberali...

[image or embed]

— Jonathan M. Katz (@katz.theracket.news) April 21, 2025 at 1:18 PM

Harper's Letter really is the pinnacle of decadence. 150 intellectuals boldly shouting "don't be rude to the rich author" while democracy died in the open in Eastern Europe and as the far right rose in North America.

[image or embed]

— Airship Chronos says TRANS RIGHTS (@airshipchronos.bsky.social) April 16, 2025 at 7:44 AM

Again, I'd love it if a reporter attempted all the signers of the Harpers Letter on the record about their feelings on free expression now. And ask what they're currently doing to help protect it.

[image or embed]

— Melissa Ryan (@melissaryan.bsky.social) April 11, 2025 at 9:44 AM

They "walked right into this trap."

I'd just like to applaud all the people who signed the Harper's letter, who took the side of the fascists who wanted to create this reality, and argued that the people who didn't want to give those fascists a stage and a microphone were creating a chilling effect on free exchange of ideas.

[image or embed]

— A.R. Moxon (@juliusgoat.bsky.social) May 9, 2025 at 6:28 AM

Where those Harper’s Letter folks at

— Anil Dash (@anildash.com) December 21, 2025 at 11:48 PM

Look at it now, from the perspective of January 2026. See where it has been going. For the right-wing, or those with reactionary tendencies, other people publicly embarrassing you — especially if they're disagreeing with you and they're making the point more elegantly, or they're citing stronger sources, or they're obviously more logical, or they appeal to the audience more — is the worst thing that can happen to you. This justifies repressing their speech. And if the rulers are increasingly fascist and authoritarian, they'll use their own feelings of embarrassment to justify killing you.

The New War on Speech: In modern US history, there has never been an attack on free expression quite like Donald Trump’s. Aryeh Neier, New York Review of Books, March 10, 2026

In case you missed it

You Can’t Pull a Lever to Write Your Book (and 69 Other Lessons)

Everything I know about writing a complicated and difficult book On November 4, the Book Bazaar on Twitch aired my 52-minute recorded v...