Thursday, July 7, 2022

Transphobic cis man performatively announcing ownership of femininity

female silhouette against peacock feathers

Jack Posobiec posted a picture of a celebrity trans man, pre-transition — the trans man already had a famous career in the days when he presented as a woman — and Posobiec commented: "Remember what they took from us".

It's plainly sexist. The implication is that women (or people who look like women) belong to men; the illusion and spectacle of femininity belongs to men. When a trans man (or, perhaps, a woman) begins presenting in a more conventionally masculine way, instead of seeing a person who is self-actualizing, there is a collective "us" from whom the feminine image has been robbed.

Rhetorically, it echoes the form of Nazi antisemitism. There is a "they" who is allegedly stealing some kind of cultural purity from "us." As a matter of Posobiec's personal history, "Posobiec targeted Jewish journalists with antisemitic hate, as Hatewatch detailed in a story about his links to the white supremacist movement." (Southern Poverty Law Center, July 8, 2020) And from the Southern Poverty Law Center's profile page on him: "He has also collaborated with white nationalists, antigovernment extremists, members of the Proud Boys, and neo-Nazis in his capacity as an operative." So the language is related. It doesn't come from nowhere.

Where Posobiec ended up: "Far-right speaker tells CPAC attendees that his goal is to 'overthrow' democracy": CNN's SE Cupp reacts to far-right conspiracy theorist, Jack Posobiec, speaking at CPAC, the Conservative Political Action Conference, to "replace" democracy. CNN video: February 23, 2024

Here's a screencap posted to Twitter, which also has a URL to Posobiec's original July 5, 2022 post on Telegram if you have to see the original for yourself.

A reminder: Transphobia is sexist. And also linked to antisemitism and fascism.


No comments:

Post a Comment

In case you missed it

You Can’t Pull a Lever to Write Your Book (and 69 Other Lessons)

Everything I know about writing a complicated and difficult book On November 4, the Book Bazaar on Twitch aired my 52-minute recorded v...