Showing posts with label native american. Show all posts
Showing posts with label native american. Show all posts

Saturday, June 15, 2024

Newitz: To be 'seen and erased at the same time'

I learned a few things about Indigenous American history from Annalee Newitz's new book Stories Are Weapons: Psychological Warfare and the American Mind.

abstract digital illustration

Look at these connections

In Chapter 2: A Fake Frontier, Newitz writes:

“Today it’s often called the ‘manifest destiny’ period [the second half of the 19th century], though at the time there was nothing manifest or obvious about what the future of the United States would look like.”

* * *

“The Indian Wars took place at a time when nobody had any idea whether the West could be ‘won.’ And yet, by the early twentieth century, most Americans accepted the idea that ‘manifest destiny’ had been the guiding principle of the Indian Wars, suggesting that the US government had always been steadfast in its commitment to owning the West. That’s because the final psychological battle of the Indian Wars hinged on the question of how the nineteenth century would be remembered.”

* * *

“…the phrase ‘manifest destiny’…was ensconced in history books for decades, affecting the perceptions of generations of young Americans. This latter feat was thanks largely to a Harvard historian named Frederick Jackson Turner, whose ‘frontier thesis’ is what popularized the idea of manifest destiny. The young professor presented his frontier thesis in a famous speech during the 1893 Columbian Exposition in Chicago. There he told the assembled crowd that westward expansion defined the American character. This was a departure from the assertions of thinkers in previous generations, including Alexis de Tocqueville, who thought of New England as the center of gravity in the United States. Instead, Turner argued, the western frontier was what forged a uniquely American identity. It was a place where settlers could reinvent themselves, shedding their European origins and constraining Old World Traditions.”

* * *

“…Turner was suggesting that Europeans became American in the nineteenth century by replacing Indigenous people. The frontier thesis was the original racial replacement theory. And the settler public loved it.”

— Annalee Newitz, Stories Are Weapons: Psychological Warfare and the American Mind. W. W. Norton, 2024. Chapter 2: A Fake Frontier.

And in Chapter 5: School Rules:

"...psyops targeting education are incredibly fungible. Today, advocates for Don't Say Gay bills and trans bans push for 'parents' rights.' Yet in the nineteenth century, legislators argued against parents' rights when it came to Indigenous children. During the Indian Wars, the US government took Indigenous children away from their families and taught values that contradicted their ancestral traditions. The justifications for residential schools were like the Don't Say Gay laws in reverse. Indigenous kids needed exposure to new ideas to help them progress, the government claimed. Parents had no right to set the curricula in these schools, nor even to visit their children on campus. Then and now, educational psyops harm children to punish — or appeal to — their parents."

And:

"Schools are places where we implant our hopes for the future in the minds of the people who will build it. When activists take away the right to discuss LGBT identity in school, they are participating in a larger project to eliminate LGBT people from the next generation of Americans. Refusing to teach kids about their history and culture is a way of erasing their futures."

And in Chapter 7: History is a Gift:

"Though the government's official stance was that there were no Indians in Coos Bay [Oregon], they nevertheless sent a number of Indigenous children to boarding school in Pennsylvania. This familiar psyop from the Indian Wars, in which Indigenous people are seen and erased at the same time, is why white people said to [Coquille tribal chief Jason] Younker's face that there were no Indigenous people in Coos Bay."

Thursday, June 15, 2023

Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) upheld

The Supreme Court ruled today, upholding the Indian Child Welfare Act.

"The Supreme Court on Thursday upheld a federal law, intended to rectify past government abuses, that gives preference to the foster care and adoption of Native American children by their relatives and tribes.

In a 7-2 decision, the court left in place the 1978 Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA), which was passed to remedy what Congress said was a disgraceful history in which hundreds of thousands of Native American children were removed from their homes by adoption agencies and placed with White families or in group settings."

The ICWA doesn't address custody disputes between parents, and today's ruling doesn't address that topic.

"The court’s ruling Thursday did not resolve the broader question of whether the child-welfare law violates equal protection guarantees by placing non-Indian families on unequal footing with Indian families in custody disputes."

— "Native adoptions can give priority to tribal families, Supreme Court rules," (subscriber gift link), Ann E. Marimow and Robert Barnes, Washington Post, June 15, 2023.

Regarding divorce with children, or child custody between unmarried parents: For more information on child custody law in your U.S. state, see Custody X Change.

Parent and child walking in the woods
Image by Lorraine Cormier from Pixabay

Wednesday, December 14, 2022

Native American philosophy (seen on Twitter)

Esther Gabara:

When Aníbal Quijano elaborated his critique of coloniality in collaboration with Immanuel Wallerstein, the two argued that the continent's history of violence against and resistance by indigenous peoples made it possible to 'speak of Americanity as a concept' that structured global modernity. Here this study has been influenced by methods and insights of long-standing research in decolonial thought led by distinct groups of theorists in the Americas, including, but not limited to, Ramón Grosfoguel (Puerto Rico/continental United States), María Lugones (Argentina/United States), Walter Mignolo (Argentina/United States), Silvia Rivera Cusicanqui (Bolivia), and Catherine Walsh (United States/Ecuador). All these thinkers recognize the influence of decolonization struggles in the 1960s and 1970s in Africa, Asia,Latin America, and the Caribbean on their current research that seeks to decolonize thought and life practices. Even so, they differentiate epistemological decolonization from that political process.

Research into Amerindian thought permeated theories of American negation in the generation of the 1960s and 1970s, in and beyond Acha's and Gullar's prefixes. The Argentine Rodolfo Kusch founded an interdiscipline he called antropología filosófica americana (American philosophical anthropology) in his landmark book La negación en el pensamiento popular (Negation in Popular Thought, 1975). Amerindian epistemological, spiritual, and affective imaginaries helped Kusch to comprehend the importance and shape of American negation and led him to break with Claude Lévi-Strauss's influential structuralist anthropology for its failure to comprehend the universality of indigenous thought...

* * *

Kusch thus identifies the limits of the European tradition he calls conocimiento (knowledge), which myopically focuses on objectivity and so produces knowledge that is ultimately univocal. Instead, he embraces the popular thought that he terms comprensión (comprehension), which values subjective emotions and opinion, and so creates forms of understanding that provide multiple answers to the same question.

Non-literary Fiction: Art of the Americas Under Neoliberalism, Esther Gabara (University of Chicago Press, 2022)

"My colleague Joey Miller (Mvskoke) & I are putting together a very cool Indigenous Philosoph(ies) event. If you are a Native scholar studying philosophy, a non-Native scholar studying Native philosophy, a Native scholar studying Native philosophy, please reach out! Please share!" — Shelbi acornXcore Nahwilet (@qaxaawut) December 8, 2022 (see www.nahwilet.com)

I saw other people tweeting in November 2022 that ICWA is "literally a genocide-prevention law" (Daniel Delgado) and that "If the Supreme Court overturns ICWA, the result will be - and I cannot stress this enough - genocide." (Kisha James) (In 2025, those accounts were gone.)

See Custody X Change for more info, updated to 2025.

flower

"In the late 1880s, around the time when the Lake Mohonk gang was advocating for a dramatic expansion of the residential school system, a Paiute man named Wovoka had a vision. He said that the Creator had come to him with a new dance, one that would bring about a better world without white settlers and their endless expansionist wars. The dead would reunite with the living, and the buffalo killed by settlers would roam the plains again. It’s not difficult to understand why this message would be profoundly moving for people who had lost so much in the Indian Wars and whose children were being taken away for reeducation by the US government. It was a story about a hopeful future, where Indigenous culture flourished and the land came back to its original caretakers. Oceti Sakowin (Great Sioux Nation) historian Nick Estes, author of Our History Is the Future, writes that the government had outlawed Indigenous dancing at that time, and therefore ‘the Ghost Dance was fundamentally oppositional in spirit.’”
Annalee Newitz, Stories Are Weapons: Psychological Warfare and the American Mind. W. W. Norton, 2024. Chapter 2: A Fake Frontier.

Great Inuit movie called Atanarjuat; not exactly the area you’re asking for but it’s really cool

[image or embed]

— Eric Hirsch🥥🌴 (@ehirsch.bsky.social) Jul 31, 2024 at 11:09 PM

In December 2024, HuffPost has a good explanation of the Leonard Peltier case.

A values-centered relational science model: supporting Indigenous rights and reconciliation in research Dominique M. David-Chavez, Michael C. Gavin, Norma Ortiz, Shelly Valdez, Stephanie Russo Carroll. Home > VOLUME 29 > ISSUE 2 > Article 11. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-14768-290211

Relatedly, see the comments on this LinkedIn post for other resources.

And this book, forthcoming in 2025:

Commonwealth by D.A. Lockhart, Kegedonce Press
Deyohahá:ge: Sharing the River of Life by Ki'en Debicki, Daniel Coleman, and Bonnie M. Freeman, WLU Press
Grandfather of the Treaties: Finding Our Future Through the Wampum Covenant by Daniel Coleman, by Wolsak & Wynn
You Were Made for This World: Celebrated Indigenous Voices Speak to Young People by Stephanie Sinclair, Penguin Random House Canada

In case you missed it

Have you seen inside the book 'To Climates Unknown'?

The alternate history novel To Climates Unknown by Arturo Serrano was released on November 25, the 400th anniversary of the mythical First ...